shape
carat
color
clarity

Moms, do you make your kids be friends with EVERYONE?

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

Sabine

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Aug 16, 2007
Messages
3,445
I''ve been spending a lot of time at our apartment pool since I''m home in the afternoons and don''t have much to do. I''ve observed some INTERESTING situations, to say the least!

Yesterday, there were 2 moms there who had boys that were about the same age. The boys had obviously played together before since they knew each other''s names. I''d guess they were about 5 or 6 years old. One mom was teaching the boy how to swim in the deep end when I got there, while the other boy was playing by himself in the shallow end with diving rings and balls.

After the swimming lesson, boy A went to the shallow end as well, and his mom got out of the pool. Boy B then proceeded to try to get boy A to play with him in various different ways...playing catch with a ball, racing to get the diving rings, etc. Boy A was pretty mean to boy B, would go after the ball when it was boy B''s turn, would take the ball and go out of boy B''s range, would take the rings from him, etc. Boy A''s mom kept telling him to play nice or they would go home, etc., and he would say okay, and then would ask his mom to come play with him. Eventually, Boy A just came out and said to Boy B "I don''t want to play with you. I don''t want to be your friend."

At this point, Boy B''s mom went over to her son and said, it''s okay, he doesn''t want to play with you, but you could tell she was just at a loss. Boy A''s mom did not say ANYTHING.

If you were Boy A''s mom, how would you have handled this? Would you force your son to play with someone just because he''s the same age, etc?

I really don''t know what I think about this. I think I would have talked with my child about how you have to be NICE to everyone and what he said was hurtful, but at the same time, if he didn''t want to play with the other boy, I don''t think I would have forced him to. What do you think?

PS - the toys belong to the pool itself, not either of the boys.
 
If I was boy A''s mom I would be embarrassed to have such a bullying little brat. And I would do more than tell him to nice to Boy B. If he kept being nasty I would take him out of the pool and make him go home for a time out and have no more pool fun for the day.

I don''t think this situation is really about making kids be friends with everyone-it''s about making your kid not treat another kid poorly. If kids don''t like each other, I wouldn''t make them play with each other (i.e. set up play dates between Boy A and Boy B if Boy A doesn''t really like Boy B), but I do think you have to make your kid treat other people nicely.
 
Date: 7/10/2009 8:32:37 AM
Author: thing2of2
If I was boy A''s mom I would be embarrassed to have such a bullying little brat. And I would do more than tell him to nice to Boy B. If he kept being nasty I would take him out of the pool and make him go home for a time out and have no more pool fun for the day.


I don''t think this situation is really about making kids be friends with everyone-it''s about making your kid not treat another kid poorly. If kids don''t like each other, I wouldn''t make them play with each other (i.e. set up play dates between Boy A and Boy B if Boy A doesn''t really like Boy B), but I do think you have to make your kid treat other people nicely.

Agreed. Well said!
 
I tell my 4 year old son that he doesn''t have to be friends with everyone, but he has to be nice and polite to everyone. There was a bully in his preschool last year that would call all the kids names and say hurtful things. My son didn''t understand why he didn''t want to be his friend and was very upset by it. I told him to just stick with the kids that are being nice to him and that hopefully the other boy would start being nicer or he wouldn''t have anymore friends.
 
when my DD says "no I don''t want to play with you" to another kid, I usually say something to my DD about being polite and nice, and ask whats wrong? then I politely just tell the other mother that she either is not herself today or something else. But I wouldn''t just ignore or not say anything at all to the other mother. I don''t try to make my kids be friends with everyone, just teach them to be kind to others.
 
if I was boy A''s mom I would have pulled him out for a talk as soon as he started acting up. I would have told him that if he couldn''t play nicely, we''d just leave (and I would follow through with that promise). I have a very little patience/tolerance for mean and bratty behavior in children. I raise my kids to treat all ppl how they would like to be treated. On that note...I don''t force my child to be friends with everyone just because all children aren''t always going to click. I do expect my children to be respectful toward other kids even if the child has different interests.
 
Just because the two boys know each others names, doesn't mean their friends! My kids know all the names of all the kids around here regardless if they are friends or not. . .Were the two moms at the pool hanging out *at all* or did it just appear that each mom/kid duo happened to be at the pool at the same time so the children saw each other?

I would never force my kids to be friends with kids they aren't naturally friends with. There is a REASON the kids usually are not friends. Last year, I became friends with a super sweet mom. Her son and my son have known each other since Kindergarten but never played together. I decided to invite the child over and it became apparent why the kids do not play together. The child was VERY mean. He not only bullied my older son, I caught him saying, "lay down, roll over. . ." to my younger one. At that point, my son had laid down on the deck about to roll over. My kids aren't the type to be bullied around, yet somehow this kid pulled this BS which went FAR beyond anything an average kid would assume he could get away with and my son fell for it (because he is not use to being bullied - neither of my kids ever seem to have issues with bullied).

Needless to say, regardless of how friendly the mom and I are, the kids won't be playing together again!!! I won't attempt to create a friendship where there isn't one especially if the child is a brat.
 

I think it''s ok for kids to set their own boundaries. They don''t have to be friends with certain kids if they don''t want to be. Boundary setting starts early!



In the case you described, it would have been cool to see the nice boy say HE didn''t want to be friends with the mean child. THAT would have been healthy boundary setting and I would have promoted that behavior in my child.

I think if I were the mom of the nice boy, in the situation you described, I would have spoken my child later. I would have told him that boy wasn''t behaving very nicely and that my son handled things very well. Then I would tell him that it was his choice as to whether or not he played with him again. If the boy was mean again, he wouldn''t have to play with him.
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top