How noticeable is the difference between a D and a G?

[Diamond Confused]

Is it worth paying the price tag for a D. I''m speaking aesthetically only. I know some people feel better knowing they have the best but in terms of what others see, is there really a difference.

Also, in terms of color can you tell the difference: can you tell the difference between a D round and a G emerald cut.

 

[LitigatorChick]

For an emerald cut, a definate yes.

 

[Nicki]

Everyone sees colour differently. So the answer is, it depends. I''m very colour sensitive, so I''d definitely notice the difference between a D round and a G emerald. Emerald cuts tend to show colour more than other cuts, as well.

 

[coatimundi_org]

yes, especially with this cut. I had an E princess, and I have a G oval. The G oval (ovals show more color--like emeralds) is a hair warmer, but I like the warmth--has a density to it that I love. The E was too cool for my taste. IMHO, I don''t think a D is worth the price tag.

What do you like? What looks the best in terms of what YOU see?

 

[Aur]

I went to a B&M and had them pull out a D and H stone (rounds). I don''t believe i''m very color sensitive because I couldn''t tell the difference in a short stare. I had to have it laid on its side on white paper for me to tell the difference.

Because of this I''m very comfortable with the G H I stones.

 

[Manmountain]

If you can find a gemologist to show you a set of color grading stones, you can see the difference. You will probably note that the color is minor in the extreme. Color grading is done pavilion side up and only under north daylight or special grading lights because reflections and slightly off color lights are too confusing. You will find D-E-F-G stones are colorless when face up.

 

[Lorelei]

Date: 1/30/2008 12:43:35 PM
Author: Nicki
Everyone sees colour differently. So the answer is, it depends. I'm very colour sensitive, so I'd definitely notice the difference between a D round and a G emerald. Emerald cuts tend to show colour more than other cuts, as well.

Ditto. Also we have to consider the individual eyesight of the viewer, sizes of the diamonds ( which can make a difference), cut quality and lighting, and which lab/s graded the diamonds to name some factors. You may be able to tell the difference between a D round and a G Emerald cut, but this is really comparing apples to oranges. The answer is - it depends - I think, with a leaning towards probably with the scenario you mention.

Also although this info is comparing colour grades of round diamonds, it still may be useful for you to see. This info is to give you an idea only, bear in mind a computer monitor cannot depict diamond colour, or lack of, accurately.

http://www.goodoldgold.com/content.php?c=14

 

[Diamond Confused]

Date: 1/30/2008 12:51:51 PM
Author: Manmountain
If you can find a gemologist to show you a set of color grading stones, you can see the difference. You will probably note that the color is minor in the extreme. Color grading is done pavilion side up and only under north daylight or special grading lights because reflections and slightly off color lights are too confusing. You will find D-E-F-G stones are colorless when face up.

Once in the setting, is it harder or easier to see color? The setting is platinum... if that makes a difference.

In your opinion, is it a bad idea to compare two different shaped stones when comparing colors? Can you compare a round to a cushion with regard to color?

 

[Fly Girl]

Another question to ask is not just whether you can see differences in color, but how much you really care about differences in color? For example, I can tell the difference in color between two random sheets of white paper, but I really don''t care about that. About 10 percent of the time, I can see the difference in body color between my F and J diamonds, but it never bothers me. When the difference in price can amount to hundreds or thousands of dollars for minute, nearly imperceptible differences, color is a great way to save some money.

I think that nearly colorless diamonds have a very special beauty.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

The only time a G stone may appear to have color is if you put a D stone on next to it. Tacori E-ring has an I color emerald cut stone and I would never have guessed that it was an I. It looks very white. So I would have no qualms at all about going with a G color in an emerald cut. G-H is really my preferred range for whiteness and value. But if money was no object, all my stones would probably be D-F!

 

[:)]

You also have to take into account the size of the stone - the larger the stone the more apt you are to see a color difference. In general, it is totally a personal preference with color.

 

[lovewhitediamonds]

here''s a G.... but it''s an asscher cut... not emerald.
I''m a color girl too... but depending on the individual stone.. I think this is pretty white....

 

[DiamondSeeker7]

Your best bet is to put them next to each other and see if you could tell the difference. Personally, I am very color sensitive. I know when we bought my diamond (from ERD) they had a F and G on the table and I could quickly tell the difference without being told which one was which. My fiance and Gary couldn''t. Its all about what you can see and what you want! Good luck!

 

[:)]

Sorry for the threadjack but... lovewhitediamonds - your Asscher is GORGEOUS!!!

And now we resume our regular thread programming...

 

[lovewhitediamonds]

Date: 1/30/2008 5:40:45 PM
Author:
Sorry for the threadjack but... lovewhitediamonds - your Asscher is GORGEOUS!!!

And now we resume our regular thread programming...

Thanks ... just wanted to show Diamond Confused that every individual stone is different.. I was hell bent on a D or E stone, and fell in love with a G... and it''s as white as can be.... (to me anyway!)

 

[honey22]

Like many others have said it''s up to the individual. I am very colour sensitive and can tell the difference between a E and F, but not a D and E, so it just depends. Have you seen different colour stones in person? I personally love the cold crisp look of a D (I just purchased one for my ering!!), but many love the warmer (some say more romantic?) look of lower colours. I think I G will still face up white, but have a slightly warmer look, but that is just to my eyes.

Also, if you are never likely to line your G ring up with other colour stones, you might never know the difference. I however, am neurotic, and went for a D for mind clean reasons too, as well as loving the cold look.

In the end, you need to buy something that looks right in your eyes, it shouldn''t matter to anyone else as long as you are happy!