Help with diamond decision

[Foundthe1]

I''ve been looking at these two diamonds for my future fiancee.
http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/3583
http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/3525

Do you think the difference in size is noticeable? Do you think the size of the bigger stone is worth going down in color?

 

[Allison D.]

You''d probably see the size difference if these stones were placed next to each other, but I doubt you''d be able to tell them apart size-wise if they were mounted and worn on the hand. They will give materially the same look.

That said, though, I''m a very happy H, SI2 owner, and I''d personally prefer getting the slightly larger H stone as long as it''s eyeclean. H, SI2 is my sweet spot for value/maximizing size. Beyond that, some people don''t prefer the very sharp look of a colorless stone and actually prefer a little warmth; it can be more flattering to the skin tone.

Either would be a fine choice.

 

[Skippy123]

Both are beautiful; I agree ask if they are eye clean.

 

[Ellen]

If eyeclean, I''d go with the H.