shape
carat
color
clarity

Help please w 9 stone Uprong or individual prong (from IDJ)

MelbourneGirl

Rough_Rock
Joined
May 30, 2011
Messages
69
Thanks for everyone’s help with my stud request recently. I will post the results when I have them!
In the meantime – I’ve been talking to Luann at IDJ about a 9 stone, 12 point ring size 6. (I’m having my first baby this year so I decided it’s time to get things I’ve always wanted for myself before I have ‘other’ things to have to consider. Last days of thinking of myself first! :o ).
So I’m really struggling deciding on the setting. In fact I’m driving myself crazy!
I went into a local B&M store to try on styles to check. I was originally going to get a 7 stone with .15points but found the slightly smaller and more stones worked better for me. In store they only had a prong setting (each stone having its own prongs) or a shared prong setting. Both with a little airline under each stone (which IDJ don’t do but they said they could). I quite like this setting and preferred the prong setting with individual prongs. However I’ve not been able to try on a Uprong setting and they just look so gorgeous on here. They sit low which looks great. But I’m worried about either losing or chipping a stone.

I asked Luann and she said that the U prong is pretty and shows more stone. Prong with an airline sits quite high. As I didn’t measure the height in the B&M I don’t know if her idea of ‘high’ is higher than what I tried so it’s not really helping me that much unfortunately.

I honestly don’t know what to do! Any advice about prongs vs uprong would be amazing. How it looks and the durability... I plan to wear the ring on its own or with other bands, so it wouldn’t be with my solitaire.

Thanks lovelies.
 
Re: Help please w 9 stone Uprong or individual prong (from I

I'm on my iPad so can't post pics but search my name and I posted about my 1/2 eternity by IDJ and I have 8x.12 stones in a size 8. Awesome finger coverage and I love the comfort of the U prong. My stones are fire balls and the U really does allow so much more light to hit the diamonds. I highly recommend that setting.
 
Re: Help please w 9 stone Uprong or individual prong (from I

Enerchi|1336618637|3191752 said:
I'm on my iPad so can't post pics but search my name and I posted about my 1/2 eternity by IDJ and I have 8x.12 stones in a size 8. Awesome finger coverage and I love the comfort of the U prong. My stones are fire balls and the U really does allow so much more light to hit the diamonds. I highly recommend that setting.

Thanks - yes I did stalk you before posting! I love your setting and it does look fab. Are you concerned about chipping or losing a stone with the open setting? does it feel chunky? I must say it looks gorgeous!
 
Re: Help please w 9 stone Uprong or individual prong (from I

Can Luann send you pictures of the top three she and Yekutiel like?
 
Re: Help please w 9 stone Uprong or individual prong (from I

Gypsy|1336622197|3191805 said:
Can Luann send you pictures of the top three she and Yekutiel like?

Thanks - I asked for photos but she only had stock photos that are available online - and real life photos show so much more... Hence I'm looking here for help. She has recommended the U prong and said it's prettiest. However I wanted to find out advice from people who had them. They all look good to me in a photo. The U prong looks so pretty but I'm nervous about chipping those little babies (maybe I'm just a nervous new mum of a 9 stone) .
 
Re: Help please w 9 stone Uprong or individual prong (from I

MelbourneGirl|1336624376|3191845 said:
Gypsy|1336622197|3191805 said:
Can Luann send you pictures of the top three she and Yekutiel like?

Thanks - I asked for photos but she only had stock photos that are available online - and real life photos show so much more... Hence I'm looking here for help. She has recommended the U prong and said it's prettiest. However I wanted to find out advice from people who had them. They all look good to me in a photo. The U prong looks so pretty but I'm nervous about chipping those little babies (maybe I'm just a nervous new mum of a 9 stone) .

If they have it in stock, Yekutiel will get you pics if you ask. If they don't have it in stock-- then I understand the issue.
 
Re: Help please w 9 stone Uprong or individual prong (from I

Hey Melbournegirl! No, I am not concerned about chipping (YIKES! Should I be???) I am pretty careful with my rings and even tho I talk a lot with my hands, I'm generally aware of what I'm doing (!!!) so I hadn't even thought of that!!

I love the size, for me and how I wear this ring, but some prefer much larger or smaller. My hands are not delicate, so smaller stones would have looked too tiny. I clean this every 3 or 4 days and it is as white as you could imagine! It sparkles away like mad.... I love this ring and it does not feel chunky at all. It will spin - what ring doesn't if it isnt an eternity? - and even when it's between my fingers, it is not an issue for me. The prongs don't hurt or pinch.

I hope you go for it - it's a beauty!!
 
Re: Help please w 9 stone Uprong or individual prong (from I

Enerchi|1336646256|3191938 said:
Hey Melbournegirl! No, I am not concerned about chipping (YIKES! Should I be???) I am pretty careful with my rings and even tho I talk a lot with my hands, I'm generally aware of what I'm doing (!!!) so I hadn't even thought of that!!

I love the size, for me and how I wear this ring, but some prefer much larger or smaller. My hands are not delicate, so smaller stones would have looked too tiny. I clean this every 3 or 4 days and it is as white as you could imagine! It sparkles away like mad.... I love this ring and it does not feel chunky at all. It will spin - what ring doesn't if it isnt an eternity? - and even when it's between my fingers, it is not an issue for me. The prongs don't hurt or pinch.

I hope you go for it - it's a beauty!!

Oh thanks so much for that feedback. That helps a lot. I had wondered about the spinning aspect. I've just enquired about the price of full eternity just in case it's kinda in scope but I dont think it will be. Maybe I will get some little ball things on the inside of the ring to help with the spin? Yes the only issue for me is feeling scared about losing a stone or chipping it. Maybe I'm just beng a baby? Hopefully someone else might have some advice if this has happened to them.
I've been looking at your pics daily. They are gorgeous!
 
Re: Help please w 9 stone Uprong or individual prong (from I

Just to keep you going - and a little variety to your daily viewing routine... here are a few more for you (have to add the 5th on a separate post)

IMG_0428.jpg

IMG_0430.jpg

IMG_0431.jpg

IMG_0565.jpg
 
Re: Help please w 9 stone Uprong or individual prong (from I

5th one. Hope this is helpful

IMG_0569.jpg
 
Re: Help please w 9 stone Uprong or individual prong (from I

Gosh they look so lovely in their little pods! Great pics. Thanks!
 
Re: Help please w 9 stone Uprong or individual prong (from I

:wavey: Melbournegirl! What is the update? did you end up ordering a 9x .12 point ring from IDJ? I love mine! I'm always so amazed by how it shines in the sun. This ring is probably one of my top 2 rings that I favour the most!!!

What has happened since your last post?
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top