HELP NEEDED PLEASE

[JJAVIER]

Hello All,

I would like to start by thanking everyone on this forum for all the knowledgeable information and support!

Well the time has finally come for me to take my relationship to the next stage and propose to my current girlfriend. We been together now for two years and couldn't ask for anyone more special. I don't have alot of time to work with since our cruise is next month (5/11) but i won't settle for less. With that said, i need your help finalizing my decision on which diamond to choose. Btw i decided to go with the Vatche Caroline setting because she likes that simple classy look. Unfortunately, my pockets right now don't stretch enough for the bigger 1-2ct i see everyone on here with but you can always upgrade later. Please let me know what you guys think about these two GIA diamonds. (I want your honest opinion so please don't hold back)

First..

.79
5.91-5.94x 3.68
G
VVS1
XXX
62.1
56
35
40.8
Med-ST,Faceted 3.5
Culet & Fluo None
HCA Score 1.6






Second..

.80
5.99-6.03x 3.63
G
VS2
XXX
60.3
57
34
40.6
Thin-Med,Faceted 3.0
Culet None
Fluo Faint
HCA Score 0.6







Thank you all in advance

 

[JulieN]

Second one is a little shallow, has some extra blue under ASET.

 

[JJAVIER]

Thank you for the input

What do you guys think about these images?