Find your diamond
Find your jewelry
shape
carat
color
clarity

help me decide

katiedid

katiedid

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Apr 9, 2007
Messages
2,264
I'm trying to decide between the ring I got and one from Tiffany - help me!

Which do you like better?

_5406.jpg

tiffring.jpg
 
The Tiffany one for me. I saw it a couple of weeks ago & its gorgeous!
 
Thanks Alex! So you've seen it in person? I really really love it but didn't know if it would be spending another $70.
 
i think the tiffany one is beautiful, both nice, but that would be my choice
 
Tiffany - hands down. It looks elegant - the other one is cute but it reminds me more of something a very young person would wear.

I've never seen that Tiffany one in person or on their website but I think it is beautiful!
 
MissGotRocks|1365948386|3426651 said:
Tiffany - hands down. It looks elegant - the other one is cute but it reminds me more of something a very young person would wear.

I've never seen that Tiffany one in person or on their website but I think it is beautiful!
Click to expand...

Exactly this.
 
Thanks you guys! You're so helpful!
 
I second everything that the others have said. DEFINITELY the Tiffany one. It's a new design and they tend to be cheapest when first introduced, so get it now! Also, it's Picasso which is something special.

Since it's a wide band, don't forget that you'll probably need a slightly larger size than you would for a narrower band.
 
Good point on the size. I think the one I got was an 8. Should I get an 8 1/2?
 
Tiffany :love:
 
I love the Tiffany one.
 
HI:

I also prefer the Tiffany ring. Since it is wide--I would go up a size. Luckily they have a great return policy.

cheers--Sharon
 
So the one I had was an 8.5. I wonder if the Tiffany one in a 9 will be too big?
 
Just noticed on the Tiffany web site the sizes only go up to an 8. hmmm
 
One more quick update. The web site is sold out of these in both the 8 and the 6 (and maybe other sizes) so it's back ordered. I was however, able to order it from the personal shopper in the NYC store so I went ahead and got the 8. If it's too small for my middle finger but I love it, I'll send it back and get a 6 for my ring finger. Thanks all for your help in deciding whether to keep the one I had or swap it for this one!
 
Tiffany for me too! :love:
 
much prefer the Tiffany one by far! glad you ordered it and can't wait to see pics!
 
Yes, I've sent this one IRL & its stunning. I did try it on ( my friend has bought one) but my fingers are much, much smaller than hers, so I can't comment on the size. I CAN say, however, that it is the most beautiful, fluid, organic ring I've ever seen. Good luck!
 
Thanks! I can't wait to see it either!
 
Ok this is hard for me but I recently saw the tiffany one in person and I have to say it knocked my socks off. It is actually on my wish list and that is saying something because normally I'm not a fan of paying the Tiffany $$$$ :oops:
 
Same here Sarahbear - love Tiffany but not the prices. But I loved this ring the first time I saw it on their web site. Didn't want to spend that much on a "fun" ring but I'd rather get something I won't get tired of. I'm worried it'll be too snug for my middle finger, so we'll see. Not sure I'd like it as a ring finger ring. I can't believe they don't make it bigger than a size 8! I'd think a lot of people would want this for their middle finger, and I don't consider an 8 a large middle finger size!
 
Can't wait to see your pictures - think you've made a great choice!
 
Oh my goodness, I love the one you got, but that Tiffany one is so spectacular! :love:
 
Another vote for the Tiffany one. Much more elegant.
 
Ooh, I love the Tiffany ring!
 
Tiffany. It looks more refined and whimsical.
 
I'll be sure to post pics when it gets here - hopefully sometime this week!
 
This Tiffany ring is on my wish list too. Looking forward to your pictures:)
 
This Tiffany ring is on my wish list too. Looking forward to your pictures:)
 
Efriede - I should have it late tomorrow!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Jewelry Blog
PriceScope-Concierge-Ad
Find prime cuts.
Top