HELP! I,VS1 or H,VS2 (Princess cut) Images attached

[Hdeuce22]

I'm undecided on which stone to go with and would like some input and/or opinions. I am color sensitive but she isn't really. I know this is only 1 color step difference but the setting I'm going with will have F/G color melee stones. Obviously the H is a little better in color and has AGS0 in light performance but is rated a 1 in polish and symmetry. The I is AGS0 across the board. By the way both stones are 1.5ct

These are the images for the H:





These are the images for the I:

 

[Niel]

Go with the I

 

[two_little_birds]

Yup, go for the "I". Far more red in the IS image.

 

[luv2lift]

I would agree to go with the I if those are your choices.

 

[chel180]

The I will be much sparkler then the H. You will not notice the color difference between the halo melee and the centre stone at those colors. The stone with the most light return will appear whiter. Go for the second stone.

 

[diamondloveaffair]

you should request a video for these 2 stones.

 

[Hdeuce22]

you should request a video for these 2 stones.

I have requested a video and I have looked at it over and over. I just cant seem to make a decision which route to go. It seems the facets on the I are larger and puts out brighter chunks of light. The H performs great under the lights and in daylight as well in the video. The H however is bright also but seems to have more of the splintered facet structure.

 

[Niel]

You said you're more color sensitive than she? Seems like people here are in agreement the I is the way to go. Feel confident in it it looks like a just fabulous stone.

 

[JulieN]

post the video and links to stones?

 

[Hdeuce22]

Here is a link to the video. The I,VS1 is the 2nd stone and the H,VS2 is the 4th stone.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pQclwi8F4SU&feature=youtu.be

 

[JulieN]

I can see the color difference in the video. Are the dimensions on the H bigger than the I?

 

[Hdeuce22]

I can see the color difference in the video. Are the dimensions on the H bigger than the I?

The I is a 1.51ct and measures 6.30x6.30
Table:65%
Depth:74%

The H is a 1.54 and measures 6.46x6.37
Table:68%
Depth:72%

 

[hearts-arrows_girl]

You really have a hard decision to make. I like the deep contrast and smaller table of the I VS1 the best. The H VS2 is gorgeous too, and looks bigger. I guess it depends on which features are most important to you. Either stone is a gorgeous winner!

 

[chel180]

You really have a hard decision to make. I like the deep contrast and smaller table of the I VS1 the best. The H VS2 is gorgeous too, and looks bigger. I guess it depends on which features are most important to you. Either stone is a gorgeous winner!

+1

 

[Hdeuce22]

Yeah I wasn't expecting to see that H,VS2 in the video so he threw me a curve ball but definitely gave me something to think about.