Help - I can''''t decide!

[Banky]

Hi - I''m having real trouble deciding on which of these jubilees I want to go with... any advice would be super helpful!

Jub #1
Carat Weight: .84
Clarity: VS1
Color: G
Shape: Jubilee brilliant
Cut External
Polish: GCAL ~ Excellent
Symmetry: GCAL ~ Very Good (5.53 x 5.49 x 3.79)
Cut Internal
Symmetry ~ Hearts & Arrows
Light Return ~ Excellent

Jub #2
Carat Weight: .86
Clarity: SI1
Color: D
Shape: Jubilee brilliant
Cut External
Polish: GCAL ~ Excellent
Symmetry: GCAL ~ Excellent (5.46 x 5.4 x 3.74)
Cut Internal
Symmetry ~ Hearts & Arrows
Light Return ~ Excellent

I''ve seen an enlarged photo of the SI1 and the inclusion isn''t really noticable... I guess I''m having an issue deciding on the clarity vs. color question (if this helps with your advice/feedback, I''m looking at a plat. setting).

Please help - any comments are welcome!

 

[Cath]

The D SI1 has better symmetry and the Brilliancescope results look phenomenal, so it gets my vote. Just confirm with GOG that the diamond is eye clean.

 

[belle]

i''m sure you can''t go wrong with either one........do you have a link to them perhaps?

 

[Banky]

Yeah, sorry I forgot to include that!

G VS1 - http://www.goodoldgold.com/jubilee_0_84ct_g_vs1.htm

D SI1 - http://www.goodoldgold.com/jubilee_0_86ct_d_si1.htm

Thanks...

 

[belle]

i like the d si1. like cath said, have gog check for eye cleanliness (unless you don''t mind a lil speck!) i''m sure it''s beautiful!!!
good luck!!!

 

[Banky]

Here is the picture of the SI1 from GOG...