Help deciding on a stone

[mcosme]

Hi fellow pricescopers
I am helping out a friend pick out an amazing ring for his girlfriend. They have decided on the following setting and JA said they can do claw prongs as the ball prongs look a bit large:
https://www.jamesallen.com/engagement-rings/halo/14k-rose-gold-floral-halo-engagement-ring-item-53439

Could you please help us decide between these two stones? Will the twinning wisp in the 0.63 carat be a concern - I like the fatter arrows on this one.

Thanks for your help!

 

[Gypsy]

No worries about a Vs2 twining wisp. I like the first one better too. It's going to be nice. Ask them if there is an option to use lower colored stones for the halo.

 

[mcosme]

No worries about a Vs2 twining wisp. I like the first one better too. It's going to be nice. Ask them if there is an option to use lower colored stones for the halo.

Thanks very much Gypsy. What colored stones should I be asking for? I/J?
Cheers

 

[flyingpig]

Hi fellow pricescopers

Could you please help us decide between these two stones? Will the twinning wisp in the 0.63 carat be a concern - I like the fatter arrows on this one.

Thanks for your help!

+1

 

[Gypsy]

No worries about a Vs2 twining wisp. I like the first one better too. It's going to be nice. Ask them if there is an option to use lower colored stones for the halo.

Thanks very much Gypsy. What colored stones should I be asking for? I/J?
Cheers

Just ask if it's even an option. See what they propose. They aren't the most flexible vendor.

 

[mcosme]

Thanks Gypsy and Flyingpig - we have placed an order for the 0.63 carat stone.

My friend actually doesn't mind the slight contrast so we will keep it at G/H stones in the halo. They are already offering to do claw prongs without any extra charge, so quite happy with their service.