Snwboarder159
Rough_Rock
- Joined
- Sep 8, 2012
- Messages
- 4
Hello,
I've spent the past couple months researching various stones as I am planning to propose in about a month. During all my research I came across this site and found some threads very useful, but also thought much was lacking. One thing I would have really liked to see were more reviews of Colored Stone retailers. I did find a thread listing many sites, though I really disliked most of the sites and they also lacked a very large selection. I eventually came across GemsNY.com either by this site or Google...don't remember...but as I could not find many decent threads on this retailer I thought I would start one.
I hope people will find my review along with those others hopefully post helpful. Please share your experiences if you've purchased from this store.
I was looking for a Ruby, Emerald, or Sapphire and out of all the sites I found, GemsNY was the best.
The Good:
They offered the widest selection, most comprehensive sorting/filtering, the most certification reports, and best overall photos. I also liked their 30 day return policy.
The Bad:
The "Discount" prices seem a little too discounted to be real. I highly doubt the appraisal is accurate, but it is sufficient to insure the stone against theft, lost, etc.
My Stone and Experience:
I ended up purchasing a Round 1.99 ct, Vivid Blue, FL, Brilliant Cut, Ceylon Sapphire (Untreated!). Price was $4,477.50 (est. at $13,500). I called the store and spoke to one of their gemologists and he answered all my questions and even pulled out the stone to look at it for me. He explained this was as flawless as a sapphire will generally get with only a few very tiny, very difficult to see inclusions under 10x. He also said there was zero zoning (which I was very concerned about). The gemologist said the stone was very well cut and had an excellent brilliance and noted the Culet came to nice point and was not cut off. Overall the stone was very symmetrical in its cut.
https://www.gemsny.com/sapphires/1.99-Carat-Round-Sapphire-SU57DRD/
I should also mention that the photo on their site was a little darker than the stone turned out to be, but was still a beautiful blue.
I found all of the information to be true and they even provided certifications from both GIA and UGL. I have to say that overall I am very satisfied with the quality of the stone and the price. Even though I highly doubt the actual discount, I do believe it is a very good price for the stone. I have seen far worse stones for not much less money. I would upload a picture of the stone, but it is currently with Green Lake Jewelry getting set into a custom ring.
I hope this review was helpful!
- Bryan
I've spent the past couple months researching various stones as I am planning to propose in about a month. During all my research I came across this site and found some threads very useful, but also thought much was lacking. One thing I would have really liked to see were more reviews of Colored Stone retailers. I did find a thread listing many sites, though I really disliked most of the sites and they also lacked a very large selection. I eventually came across GemsNY.com either by this site or Google...don't remember...but as I could not find many decent threads on this retailer I thought I would start one.
I hope people will find my review along with those others hopefully post helpful. Please share your experiences if you've purchased from this store.
I was looking for a Ruby, Emerald, or Sapphire and out of all the sites I found, GemsNY was the best.
The Good:
They offered the widest selection, most comprehensive sorting/filtering, the most certification reports, and best overall photos. I also liked their 30 day return policy.
The Bad:
The "Discount" prices seem a little too discounted to be real. I highly doubt the appraisal is accurate, but it is sufficient to insure the stone against theft, lost, etc.
My Stone and Experience:
I ended up purchasing a Round 1.99 ct, Vivid Blue, FL, Brilliant Cut, Ceylon Sapphire (Untreated!). Price was $4,477.50 (est. at $13,500). I called the store and spoke to one of their gemologists and he answered all my questions and even pulled out the stone to look at it for me. He explained this was as flawless as a sapphire will generally get with only a few very tiny, very difficult to see inclusions under 10x. He also said there was zero zoning (which I was very concerned about). The gemologist said the stone was very well cut and had an excellent brilliance and noted the Culet came to nice point and was not cut off. Overall the stone was very symmetrical in its cut.
https://www.gemsny.com/sapphires/1.99-Carat-Round-Sapphire-SU57DRD/
I should also mention that the photo on their site was a little darker than the stone turned out to be, but was still a beautiful blue.
I found all of the information to be true and they even provided certifications from both GIA and UGL. I have to say that overall I am very satisfied with the quality of the stone and the price. Even though I highly doubt the actual discount, I do believe it is a very good price for the stone. I have seen far worse stones for not much less money. I would upload a picture of the stone, but it is currently with Green Lake Jewelry getting set into a custom ring.
I hope this review was helpful!
- Bryan