shape
carat
color
clarity

Five Hundred Miles, Fifteen Months, Two Countries, Many Frequent Flyer Points..

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

canadiangrrl

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Jun 10, 2003
Messages
787
...and one imperfectly perfect ring.
1.gif


I am now officially engaged to the kindest, brightest, wittiest guy I''ve ever known.
1.gif


Mr. Canadiangrrl (his new title, heh heh) and I have been weathering the long-distance thing (the 500 miles) since the outset of our relationship (the 15 months. And I will stop with the parentheses now.) It has been expensive and grueling and I don''t recommend it, but having said that, he is just so worth it.
1.gif


We had been planning on becoming officially engaged this weekend for the past month or so. So it was a let down when Mr. Canadiangrrl called me last week and said that he didn''t yet have my ring. He explained that he hadn''t yet received it from Rich Sherwood, who was doing the appraisal. He told me that it wouldn''t arrive until after I''d departed. Lies, I tell you, lies.
1.gif
I was rather disappointed as I won''t see him again until Thanksgiving. Turns out that Mr. Canadiangrrl just wanted to surprise me. I am the pragmatist, he''s the romantic, so I should have seen it coming.
2.gif


We spent Friday night handing out candy to the hordes of kids who came by his house. I had asked him ahead of time to put aside some Tootsie Rolls from the loot he''d purchased to hand out to the trick-or-treaters, as they''re my all-time favourite candy. After the last of the kids came by, we headed to the kitchen. Mr. Canadiangrrl said that he had a little something for me for Hallowe''en. This did not set off my radar because Mr. Canadiangrrl is forever doing kind and thoughtful little things.
1.gif
He handed me a handmade card and a little ceramic cup filled with Tootsie Rolls. He had written me a very moving letter inside the card. Once I finished reading it, he said, "How ''bout a Tootsie Roll?" So I took the top one out of the little cup. It seemed oddly shaped, and I said, "Gee, quality control just isn''t what it used to be." I unwrapped it and lo and behold, there was my ring.
1.gif
Forgot to answer Mr. Canadiangrrl''s "Will you marry me please?" because I had simultaneously begun laughing and crying. What a trip.
1.gif


My ring is completely and utterly gorgeous. It is icy, fiery, and bright, and I see arrows, which is cool.
1.gif
It is a size 5.5, which used to be my ring size, but it''s slightly too big right now. I am running quite a bit at present and have a hard time keeping weight on when I am in this mode, so I guess my finger shrunk too. Not sure if I should get it sized or not at this point?

We elected to go with Dirt Cheap Diamonds out of Maryland, and I cannot say enough good things about both Jim Schultz and Joshua Cales. Mr. Canadiangrrl expressed trepidation about purchasing an engagement ring online, and it helped that DCD is only an hour outside of DC, where he resides. Also, the nature of his job is such that he''s often travelling, and so he had neither the time nor the inclination to research diamonds on the internet. So I made it my mission to become somewhat educated about diamonds.
1.gif


After searching online, asking questions, viewing diamonds in person, and pestering Rich Sherwood, God Among Appraisers, I came to the following conclusions: 1) I wanted a stone that was F or better in colour. Nothing against warmer stones, but I found after viewing stones in person that I really like the icy, complete absence of colour in the D-E-F range. 2) I wanted a thin, platinum six-prong setting, and I liked the fact that DCD''s settings are 900 PLAT/10 Iridium. From what I''ve read, this combo seems to maintain its lustre fairly well. 3) Clarity was no biggie. In fact, I kind of like some inclusions, just as long as they''re not black, and the stone is reasonably eyeclean and doesn''t scream "Hey, I''m horribly included!" from a foot away. 4) It had to be well cut. It had to score 2 or better on the HCA. 5) I had to please Mara, and go for size.
1.gif
It had to be over a carat, which to me, is plenty big. 6) It could not be hideously expensive. Mr. Canadiangrrl is a spender. Canadiangrrl is an inveterate saver. The twain meet somewhere in the middle.
1.gif


This was the stone I found at the beginning of my search back in July, and after all of the ensuing research, it''s the one we ended up with.
1.gif
It''s a 1.18 AGS certed RB, F colour, I1 clarity, and it scored 1.8 TIC on the HCA. There is a tiny white imperfection to the side of the girdle that is now pronged, and a feather under the table that I swear I cannot see. I have tilted it back and forth under various lighting conditions, and while I am blinded by the rainbows this thing shoots off, I cannot see the feather.
1.gif


Before we purchased the stone, Jim Schultz visually evaluated it and gave it a thumbs up. It was then sent to Rich Sherwood, Giant Among Gemologists, for appraisal. Rich also gave it a thumbs up. He did a bang-up appraisal, and then sent it on to Mr. Canadiangrrl.

I would like to thank a whole bunch of contributors to this forum for their thoughtful feedback to my questions. Mara, Giangi, Garry, Rhino, you''re all amazing. Leonid, thanks for creating this venue - if I hadn''t stumbled across it this past summer during my research phase, I would be far less knowledgeable about diamonds than I am now. Jim and Josh at DCD - thanks for selling us a gorgeous rock and a beautiful setting. DCD''s customer service is really top-knotch, and we recommend them unreservedly. And Rich - thank you so much for patiently answering all of my questions - you were really and truly a huge help to us, and really, I don''t hold the fact that you''re from Texas against you. Much.
1.gif


And...thanks most of all to my blue-eyed Southern boy, who came along to remind me that integrity, brains, loyalty, and manners still exist in the realm of ''dating''.
1.gif
Not a day goes by that I don''t mentally fall on my knees and thank the powers that be for putting you in my path. On our very first date in Jacksonville, Florida, I knew in my bones that I''d marry you someday. Thanks for playing "Stupid Answers to Stupid Questions", thanks for indulging my love of hairy, massively-shedding, drooling dogs weighing 150 lbs., thanks for singing along with Cake in the car, thanks for only slightly gritting your teeth when you hear "Do you like the name (fill in the blank) for a girl?" for the hundredth time, thanks for making me completely dissolve in laughter at least three times per week...just thanks.
1.gif


Will post some eye candy for the troops as soon as it''s available from the digital.
1.gif
 
Hi!
1.gif
I'm speechless!
2.gif
You, holder-of-awesome-happiness you!
5.gif

All the best from this side of Pricescope!
10.gif
 
This is a wonderful vignette, canadiangrrl! Thank you for sharing the story. I have to know more about the 150 lb drooling dog, though. I have a tiny (110 lb) drooling dog named Biscuit. Does Cake happen to be your dog's name? Do you know the Henry and Mudge books? (If not, rush right out and buy them! Whether or not you plan to have children.) And which names *do* you like for a girl?

Good luck!!!
 
AWESOME STORY - Congrats Congrats!! We look forward to seeing your beauty!!!

love.gif
 
Thanks everyone.
1.gif
I cannot stop smiling.
1.gif
1.gif
1.gif


AGBF, what kind of pup is Biscuit?? We won't be getting a dog of our own until next summer, but I have always loved the sweet and benevolent Newfie, so that's the 150 lbs. dog that I'm referring to. Mr. Canadiangrrl had never met a Newf up until last year. He has always owned dogs who are somewhat smaller and relatively non-shedding. We went to the Royal Agricultural Winter Fair in Toronto last November, and his frozen expression of shock upon seeing SIX GIANT NEWFIES romping together was absolutely priceless.
1.gif


Cake is actually the name of one of our favourite bands. I've never read or heard of the Henry and Mudge books, but I'll look them up.
1.gif
As for names for a girl - Molly, Ella, Nora.
1.gif
 
Congratulations, Canadiangrrl. What a great story!! Can't wait to see pictures!!
appl.gif





Diamondlil
 
----------------
On 11/3/2003 1:19:35 AM canadiangrrl wrote:
<BR thanks for making me completely dissolve in laughter at least three times per week...just thanks.
1.gif


-------------


This statement speaks volumes.

Congrats to your fiance & Best Wishes to you.

A heart warming post. THANKS!
 
Wow Canadian!!!!!!! I'm so happy for you and thanks for mentioning me!!
1.gif
9.gif
appl.gif

It sounds like you got a super stone... Gotta tell you... I love good I1s... They cost a bunch less but are just as beautiful, if you don't care about a little speck or, even better, if you can hide it under a prong. You definitely made a wise choice! (And got an EGL E/SI 2
2.gif
)
 
Congratulations!!! I love his surprise, it's low key but still so very romantic--fav candy and all. I love the quality control comment--I would have thought the same thing about the funky shaped candy.




The stone sounds incredibly lovely and you probably more than met your reasonable-$$ requirements with the I1 clarity--and finding one that is eye clean to you is so very cool--way to maximize the budget. I can't wait to see how long it takes for shrinkage to set in...because IT DOES!
rodent.gif





I'm SOOO flattered that I was a # on your list of requirements and I wasn't the last one either!! Wooo.
rolleyes.gif





Pictures!
 
----------------
On 11/3/2003 9:14:13 AM canadiangrrl wrote:

Thanks everyone.
1.gif
I cannot stop smiling.
1.gif
1.gif
1.gif



AGBF, what kind of pup is Biscuit?? We won't be getting a dog of our own until next summer, but I have always loved the sweet and benevolent Newfie, so that's the 150 lbs. dog that I'm referring to. Mr. Canadiangrrl had never met a Newf up until last year. He has always owned dogs who are somewhat smaller and relatively non-shedding. We went to the Royal Agricultural Winter Fair in Toronto last November, and his frozen expression of shock upon seeing SIX GIANT NEWFIES romping together was absolutely priceless.
1.gif


----------------


Biscuit is a Lab. He just happens to be much bigger than the breed standards :-). His head is in one spot and his tail is knocking things down in another room. It's the tail that never quits :-).

I would give *anything* to see six bounding Newfoundlands! That would be a great home video, too!

Deb
 
"Will post some eye candy for the troops as soon as it's available from the digital."

In Tootsie Roll wrappers??!!
2.gif


What a story! Many Congrats! Looking forward to the pics!
love.gif
 
What a great story! Congratulations! a holloween to rembember
appl.gif
 
What a great post- CONGRATULATIONS !! I wish you both the very best and hope you'll always be as exceedingly happy as you are now.
 
----------------
On 11/3/2003 1:19:35 thanks for making me completely dissolve in laughter at least three times per week...just thanks.
1.gif


blockquote>


I tried to edit my post. *This* is the statement that speaks volumes!

We want pics!
 
Good story Canadiangrrrl - congratulations. Must be something about the ladies of that country - my fiancee has bee going 'grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr' at me for years and now I'm joining in!
naughty.gif
 
I am really lousy with the digital (as you can tell by this pic) and I've only just started to use the macro...so this isn't the greatest shot on earth, but here it is.
1.gif
 
The ring or the fiance?




Hee
1.gif
 
Mara, I pm'd you.

BECAUSE I AM A MORON, THAT'S WHY.
9.gif


RELP!
1.gif
 
The picture above is indeed of (a rather somber looking) Mr. Canadiangrrl. And it's there until I can get Leonid to remove it.
2.gif
Glad I didn't mistakenly load some other, uh, shots.
11.gif




Let's try this again, shall we??

123456789.jpg
 
Will try improve with the digital shots, I realize these aren't great. Here's one on my scarily white hand.
1.gif


DSC00327.jpg
 
Beautiful setting! The diamond looks very big (drool) which is always a good thing!
1.gif
 
Thank you Mara.
1.gif
It's funny, because I was thinking that it might look smaller than its carat weight because of the small table (54.2%, taken from the appraisal.) But it sure doesn't.
1.gif


Here are the rest of the specs from Rich's appraisal:

Depth - 61%
Crown - 34.0 average angle, 15.4% average height
Pavilion - 40.8 average angle, 43.1% average depth
Girdle Thickness - Extremely Thin to Medium, Frosted
Culet - None
Polish - Excellent
Symmetry - Excellent

Light Return Analysis - Very Good (0.99 & 0.98)
Non-Leakage Analysis - Very Good (1.01 & 1.02)
Light/Dark Constrast - Very Good (1.02)
Non-Fisheye effect - Very Good (1.00)

I wish I could post the diffused lighting picture and the Ideal Scope picture, they're really cool.
1.gif
The Ideal Scope pic is dark red and black, no white.
1.gif
1.gif
1.gif
 
Congrats & what a nice story........
 
Nice numbers!!
1.gif





Why can't you post the other pictures? I'd love to see the IS image!
 
Mara, the IS & diffused lighting pics are on paper. I'd take a digital pic of them, but Mr. Canadiangrrl (thanks for removing his pic, Leonid!) is in possession of the camera. The diffused lighting pic shows the lovely dark arrows.
1.gif
I don't have a scanner or I'd scan them in for you.

AGBF, I just re-read your post - and speaking of pics, we *must* see one of Biscuit, the Steroid Lab.
9.gif
I love Labs almost as much as Newfies (I love swimming and adore water-loving dogs) but they're just not big enough and they don't drool 24/7.
2.gif
Your big guy sounds terrific, though.
 
-----------
And Rich - thank you so much for patiently answering all of my questions - you were really and
truly a huge help to us, and really, I don't hold the fact that you're from Texas against you.
Much.
-----------

HEY! You can talk about my momma, you can talk about my papa, but don't you be talking about my Texas.



IdealScope photo and diffused white light photo follows...

DSC00133.JPG
 
Wow I *love* the idealscope picture!!
love.gif
Very pretty! Discriminating eye!
rodent.gif
 
Wow, I would never in a million years have guessed that that's an I1.

Was it hard to find a beautifully cut I1? Did you look at others?
 
I began searching for a diamond at the end of June, when I realized that Mr. Canadiangrrl wasn't going to stop talking about this "getting married" bit.
1.gif
Began doing some online research and stumbled across Pricescope. Did the usual P'scope searches - had no idea what I was looking for.
1.gif
One of the stones that I came across was this one. I emailed Josh Cales at DCD about it, and about another stone. Both were held by the same broker. The broker pulled both stones and examined them. One of the stones he didn't recommend, and one of the stones he highly recommended - this one. The fact that the broker and the vendor were NOT willing to recommend one of the two stones helped to bolster my confidence.
1.gif


I searched for other stones online, still having zero clue as to what I really wanted in terms of carat weight, colour, or clarity. All I knew is that I wanted something very well cut. Viewing actual stones & trying on rings in B&M stores was the real key in helping me determine my priorities.

We didn't set out to find an I1. I've realized that I'm not overly hung up on clarity, so long as it passes my eyeclean test - the inclusions needed to be very, very difficult to locate (and I have 20/15 vision, thank you LASIK.)
1.gif
This one just happened to meet our specs in terms of cut, colour, size, and clarity, and the price was terrific. I think we happened to get lucky, 'cause I've seen some I1's that I definitely would not have bought.

I feel like the human I1 media kit. Go I1's!!!
9.gif
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top