Finale Choice - Which one

[takingtheplung]

Sorry for hogging the board these past couple of weeks.. I am purchasing one of these two stones tomorrow.

choice 1
$11,600
http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/3634
AGS 0 F Vs2

Choice 2
$10,665 + tax
AGS 000
G
VS2
7.16 - 719 x 4.33
table - 55.7
depth - 60.4
crown 34.8
pavillion - 40.7
polish/symmetry - 0
flourescence - negl.
Light score is 0

 

[takingtheplung]

choice 2 is 1.34 carat.

 

[hedarud]

Choice 2 is my choice, it has better proportions

 

[Regular Guy]

Date: 10/11/2007 8:22:41 PM
Author: hedarud
Choice 2 is my choice, it has better proportions

Better from what point of view?

It''s easy to prefer F over G...but I''m not otherwise prepared to vote...

Nice to have two 0 options...

 

[Ellen]

I see no reason not to pick two. It will be bright white, and it''s facing up a bit bigger, at less money.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

I''d have to know where #2 was from. If it is from a vendor with a lifetime trade in policy with 100% value, then I might go with that one. But #1 does have a higher color grade and I know the vendor is excellent. #1 also is a hearts and arrows stone, and we are not told that about #2. So from what I know, I''d have to choose the first one, because I know all the information on that stone and vendor.