Final Decision

[One Diamond]

Here are the two choices. Let me know which one you guys think is a better value. I do believe ring #2 is a better stone but it is a bit more in cost because of that. Ok, here they are!

#1
AGS000 1.05 VS1 G (6.52-6.55 X 4.02mm)
Depth - 61.6%
Table - 57%
Crown Deg - 34.4
Pavilion Deg - 40.9

#2
AGS000 (Heart & Arrow) 1.07 VS1 G (6.63-6.68 X 4.01mm)
Depth - 60.3%
Table - 56%
Crown Deg - 34.1
Pavilion Deg - 40.7

* Both have Inert (Negligible) florescence
* Ring #2 is 14% more expensive (May be able to get ring #1 for even cheaper; Ring #2 not moving on price)

Thanks so much! Thanks James for your help already! Keep me posted.

 

[dbretton]

Buy them both. Compare them, then keep the nicer one, provided that the beauty outweighs the cost differential.

-Dennis

 

[hoorray]

Agreed! They both score well on the HCA, so pick whichever one looks best vis-a-vie the price to you.