Expert help!!! deciding between two diamonds with images

[dcloud]

Hi to all, i've finally narrowed down my search

i've found two diamonds which i am tossing between and would love some opinion regarding the images/value for the money


Diamond 1.
1.11 Ct E VS1 (a cut above) AGS 0 with all Ex
Idealscope


Heart and arrows



Diamond 2
1.02 Ct F VVS2 AGS 0 with all Ex

Idealscope


Heart and arrows




i am told that the optical symmetry of the second is slightly off, i think i can see it but its not that significant?

anyway i am really unsure

the best part is the E VS1 is cheaper than the F VVS2 and larger... i have been looking at the idealscope images and to my untrained eye the is of the second diamond is better????

anyway i appreciate all comments and feedback

 

[iluvdiamonds2]

I'm no gemologist, but If all things are the same, I'd go for the whiter color E and hey , it looks bigger ? Go for that one!

 

[diamondseeker2006]

The ACA is the better stone. And I don't know if you are aware but there is a computer pricing glitch on WF right now, and they are honoring the current prices if you order within 24 hours of the site priced being corrected. That could result in some nice savings for you!

 

[Christina...]

I'd choose the E VS1 ACA as well, and wow, good news about the price glitch! (well maybe not for WF).

 

[dcloud]

thanks yeah i think so too, will ask where the inclusion i think its a pinpoint in the middle for the ACA and yes the glitch is saving me a fair bit, what is your opinion of the IS pictures of the first one? is it excellent or more verygood - excellent

 

[dcloud]

thought i'ld just update... thanks for all who chimed in, went with the ACA... and yes when they did update the pricing it was.. substantially different time to hit the drawing board for the custom... thanks once again!

 

[Gypsy]

I wouldn't pay for VVS clarity. It's a waste of money.

The E VS1 is the one I'd pick of those two. But honestly I'd for for a G VS2 and eek out more size.