shape
carat
color
clarity

EC/Asscher experts - opinions on cut of this 6ct stone?

Phoenix

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Oct 5, 2006
Messages
9,975
and is it an Asscher or an EC?
(in the pic, it looks like an Asscher to me)

I'd love to hear comments from Asscher/EC lovers too.

TIA

6ct H VS1 EC.jpg
 
I can't really read anything clearly on the report... and I'm not an expert by any stretch.. but if the stone is ~ 11.5 X 9 then it's too elongated to be an asscher. I really like "fatter" emeralds like this one would be :bigsmile:
Do you have any pics??
 
If the culet comes to a point its an off square asscher, if it has a keel culet then it is a wide EC.
The report shows a keel
 
woooooooooooo eeee 6 ct emerald!

Sorry, that is all that comes to mind! :lickout:
 
petrock<3 said:
woooooooooooo eeee 6 ct emerald!

Sorry, that is all that comes to mind! :lickout:
ditto!!!
 
Karl_K said:
If the culet comes to a point its an off square asscher, if it has a keel culet then it is a wide EC.
The report shows a keel

Thank you, Karl. I was hoping you'd chime in.

Based on the rpt and numbers therein, what would you say about the likely cut (ie. optical performance) of this stone? Is there sufficient infor there? If not, what else can I ask for?
 
oranges said:
I can't really read anything clearly on the report... and I'm not an expert by any stretch.. but if the stone is ~ 11.5 X 9 then it's too elongated to be an asscher. I really like "fatter" emeralds like this one would be :bigsmile:
Do you have any pics??

Not really. There's one but it's even more fuzzy than the report. And I can't copy it either. I think they've done it on purpose so the pic cannot be copied and pasted.

Yes, it does seem like a more squarish EC.
 
slg47 said:
petrock<3 said:
woooooooooooo eeee 6 ct emerald!

Sorry, that is all that comes to mind! :lickout:
ditto!!!

You ladies are too cute! woooooooeeeee is right!! :bigsmile:
 
Phoenix said:
Karl_K said:
If the culet comes to a point its an off square asscher, if it has a keel culet then it is a wide EC.
The report shows a keel

Thank you, Karl. I was hoping you'd chime in.

Based on the rpt and numbers therein, what would you say about the likely cut (ie. optical performance) of this stone? Is there sufficient infor there? If not, what else can I ask for?
not even close to enough info

need lots of pictures and preferably video and the crown height
 
Phoenix,
I was thinking.... do you think that you would be satisfied with a 6 carat emerald instead of the 5 carat round you've always been coveting? I don't want you to get an emerald and still not be 100% happy since they are totally different, but equally gorgeous looks!
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top