Find your diamond
Find your jewelry
shape
carat
color
clarity

Down to the final 4, Which 1 is your favorite??

D

deezy455

Rough_Rock
Joined
Mar 23, 2013
Messages
27
So I've decided to go with B2C, simply because they seem to have the cheapest prices, and I like how they have the HCA score as a filter option.

These are my ultimate final 4 choices (with my top 2 priorities being eye clean, and sparkle):

http://www.b2cjewels.com/dd-3569700-1.51-carat-Round-diamond-J-color-VS2-Clarity.aspx?sku=3569700&utm_source=pricescope.com&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=pricescope.com
1.7 HCA

http://www.b2cjewels.com/dd-3021545-1.52-carat-Round-diamond-J-color-VS2-Clarity.aspx?sku=3021545&utm_source=pricescope.com&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=pricescope.com
0.6 HCA

http://www.b2cjewels.com/dd-3491167-1.51-carat-Round-diamond-J-color-VS2-Clarity.aspx?sku=3491167&utm_source=pricescope.com&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=pricescope.com
1.7 HCA

http://www.b2cjewels.com/dd-3599614-1.53-carat-Round-diamond-J-color-VS2-Clarity.aspx?sku=3599614&utm_source=pricescope.com&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=pricescope.com
1.4 HCA


I know there are not pictures of the diamonds or ASET images yet (I requested them though, but who knows how long that will take). However, given the information that's available, which one would you buy???

Thanks guys so much, sorry for being so wishy washy...it's just such a tough decision and its very overwhelming for me... :confused:
 
I'd probably go for the one scoring 0.6. We can really only go on the HCA because we can't see the GIA certificates on B2C. But that is a score generally found in super-ideal cuts (I know, it's a weeding tool, but it's all we've got) and the price is right at 8.3k, bank wire. I think it looks good!

I think you should take the Very Good cut diamond out of the mix. It won't be as sparkly as the Excellent cuts.

ETA: I've just seen that you are waiting on ASETs. We will have much more info once those come in. Don't do anything hasty! The experts here should look at those before you make a decision, in order to ensure the best stone for your money.
 
Just did a quickie browse on JA for you and GOG and found these 2

I like this one - same price range, slightly smaller, an "I" colour, SI2, GIA XXX and 1.5 HCA
http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/10670/

or 1.33 J, VS2, AGS Ideal, HCA 1.3
http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/9974/

Just ideas - and from GOG, they come with all the 'bells and whistles' you are asking for (but may not get...) from BC2. Worth looking into!
 
A lower HCA score below 1.0 is not better than a 1.2 or 1.8. So my tendency would definitely not be to go for the lowest HCA score. Post the idealscope images once you get them and it will be much easier for us to give you an opinion. But I also like the GOG stones that Enerchi linked. I have bought from GOG several times because with them, I know everything I need to know to make a wise purchase and I am one who really appreciates their trade in policy. :lol:
 
You certainly do appreciate that policy, DS! :D So nice of you to test-drive it for everyone else!

Yeah, I know 0.6 isn't necessarily better than 1.2 etc. But it's just that I've never seen a 0.6 outside the super-ideal Signature ranges, so it seemed a good bet only because I thought we were relying on the HCA. But then I realised that we were getting images. :appl:
 
For me, based on currently available information, of the 4 stones, I actually prefer the 4th stone. Its numbers are closer to signature stones at 34.5/40.8. As mentioned, an ASET follow up would be nice.
 
What is the measurment you speak of 34.5/40.8 on the 4th choice darkadam?

Those diamonds are nice on goodoldgold, and I love all the pictures already included. However they are .2 karat smaller for the same price, and they don't have the "design your own ring" feature on that site, so I am worried that I wouldn't get the ring before my june 22nd deadline..

Sounds like it's coming down to option 2 and 4......
 
The first I color diamond from GOG is gorgeous--the light performance is guaranteed to be tops. And it's whiter (slightly). Many would prefer it to a lesser performing 1.5. Wait till you get the IdealScope on the 1.5's and then make a decision. I wouldn't purchase without a reflector study (ASET or IS).

What's preventing you from buying from GOG (or another vendor), and then having it set at your preferred setting vendor in the custom design? You may even be able to have them ship it directly to the setter. Have you designed the setting yet?
 
hmm...I never considered buying a diamond from GOG and then having it made at a different vendor.

I wonder if I would receive it by june 22nd if I did this, considering this would be a longer process??

Anyone know if I could buy the diamond from GOG and have them ship it to B2C and have B2C set the stone in their setting?

This is the setting that I like:

http://www.b2cjewels.com/Diamond-Accent-Settings/Cathedral-Diamond-Engagement-Ring-14K-White-Gold-(1-5-cttw..)-6395-1.aspx


With so much high praise for the first I color diamond from GOG, I am seriously considering getting that one now! One concern I have about this diamond however is all the inclusions... Do you guys think this diamond will be eye clean??
 
Your link for the setting didn't turn out right...
But in any case, if GOG can't ship directly to B2C, then definitely check out the settings that GOG does offer. You could even just send that link to Marie at Good Old Gold (she seems to run the setting part), and she'll help you find something that's very close. I've been amazed at how good the customer service is at all these places (GOG, JA, ERD, DBL... I've been all over). Just ask, and they're very honest about what they can offer.
 
http://www.goodoldgold.com/SettingsGallery/vatche_rings/

Very bottom left is extremely close. You might even prefer some others there. I will say that Vatche prices are a little higher than the B2C setting, but Vatche is supposed to be great quality. You might be able to find approximate prices on since1910.com, as they're not listed on GOG.

Again, if you can, probably wait until you get IS or ASET from B2C, because you may very well be getting a larger diamond and similar predicted performance for the same price.
 
deezy455|1370749721|3461911 said:
What is the measurment you speak of 34.5/40.8 on the 4th choice darkadam?

Those diamonds are nice on goodoldgold, and I love all the pictures already included. However they are .2 karat smaller for the same price, and they don't have the "design your own ring" feature on that site, so I am worried that I wouldn't get the ring before my june 22nd deadline..

Sounds like it's coming down to option 2 and 4......
Click to expand...

Sorry, i was referring to the crown and pavilion angles in the GIA cert
 
How did you see the pavillion and crown angles in the GIA cert???

when i clicked on "view certificate" it says "The digital certificate copy for this diamond is not loaded.
Please give us your details and we will email you the certificate." and i have to fill out information to get it....
 
oh wow...cool, didn't know that...

Now I can see the inclusions,

Diamond #2 has twining wisps on the table.

Diamond #4 has a couple crystals in the middle of the table, and some feathers, needles and crystals on the side.

Which do you guys think would be more eye clean??
 
deezy455|1370801376|3462143 said:
oh wow...cool, didn't know that...

Now I can see the inclusions,

Diamond #2 has twining wisps on the table.

Diamond #4 has a couple crystals in the middle of the table, and some feathers, needles and crystals on the side.

Which do you guys think would be more eye clean??
Click to expand...

Might have to get the B2C gemologists evaluation to properly judge that...
 
Sorry I have no idea how to post images, so bare with me as I experiment :D

I was only able to get a close up of diamond #2, and an ASET of diamond #4 so far, still waiting on the closeup and ASET of the other.






above is the diamond #4 ASET


Thoughts so far on these?

3021545-danielg-1.jpeg

3599614-danielg-2__1_.png
 
Hey guys,
So I've just been informed that this is ALL the info that I can get, the closeup of #2 and the ASET of #4.

Going off this incomplete information, and the GIA reports, Which would you guys choose??

#2 or #4????

I really wanna buy today as the deadlines approaching..... :(


THANKS!
 
This is the problem i have with b2c, they don't have options to hold and they don't provide idealscope images in most cases. On other hand diamonds sell out really fast :(
 
OK, I'm like 99% sure that I'm going to go for option #2:

http://www.b2cjewels.com/dd-3021545-1.52-carat-Round-diamond-J-color-VS2-Clarity.aspx?sku=3021545&utm_source=pricescope.com&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=pricescope.com
0.6 HCA

there is also a closeup picture of it 2 posts above

The B2C sales team sent me this email:

"Hi Daniel,

I just received an update for my partners and as per my opinion, stock # 3021545 is the better of the two as it has better sparkle and twining wisps are not visible to the naked eyes. I've reserved the same for you for the next 24 hours. Please revert with your opinion."

So seems like #2 is the RIGHT choice (even though I haven't seen a ASET picture of it)......right guys?

Just looking for some positive confirmation...... :naughty:

thanks guys for all your help!
 
I know you are on a deadline of June 22, but do *YOU* Feel comfortable with this diamond based on the info you have?

I don't want to put any doubt in your mind, but that's one of the things that places like BGD, WF, GOG for example, do so well at - supplying you with all the info for a completely enlightened and informed decision. But - that's neither here nor there if you are good with #2!!

Congrats on the upcoming engagement - June 22 will be my 28th wedding anniversary, so I think you have picked a FANTASTIC day to aim for! :D :bigsmile: :D
 
Wow 28 years..Congrats Enrichi!

Yes I do feel comfortable since:
- It got a 0.6 HCA score
- Got an excellent cut GIA score
- The Sales guy at B2C reccomended this one over #4 (I'm assuming I can trust him)
- Twining wisps aren't "that" bad of an inclusion, so should be eye clean

I guess these are good enough reasons for me to buy without seeing an ASET image. Plus on those other sites you mentioned, for this price range I would have to go down .2 karats to about a 1.3 karat.
 
deezy455|1370917652|3463150 said:
Wow 28 years..Congrats Enrichi!

Yes I do feel comfortable since:
- It got a 0.6 HCA score
- Got an excellent cut GIA score
- The Sales guy at B2C reccomended this one over #4 (I'm assuming I can trust him)
- Twining wisps aren't "that" bad of an inclusion, so should be eye clean

I guess these are good enough reasons for me to buy without seeing an ASET image. Plus on those other sites you mentioned, for this price range I would have to go down .2 karats to about a 1.3 karat.
Click to expand...

Then there you are - you have found the perfect diamond for you!! I hope you'll share pics with us when it is set! Its going to be gorgeous!!

(and just because I'm super curious- what's the significance of June 22 to you?? I'll share a silly little piece of trivia about our wedding day - 24 of 27 years, it has rained on our anniversary!! The day we were married - I'm sure Noah was building an ark! lol! So we are always curious to see if it will be another raining day or one of the VERY few sunny June 22nds!!)
 
I think B2Cjewels have a generous return policy that covers shipping in the US. If you don't like it, you can always send it back. But chances are, you would be fine.
 
haha.. wow that's crazy that it rained 90% of the days! hope it doesn't rain this year cause I wanna do it on a hike.. :D
Just picked that day as an arbitrary day..haha

So now the next step is picking the ring. So I want a pave ring, I was thinking 2-2.5mm is a good size, don't want it to thin, and don't want it to thick making the diamond look small (she has small hands 4.5 size finger I think).

Narrowed it down to 5, included your fave Kaaty (I think its very pretty as well):

http://www.b2cjewels.com/Round/1/5994/Diamond-Accent-Settings/Cathedral-Pave-Set-Round-Diamond-Engagement-Ring-14K-White-Gold(1-5-cttw).aspx

http://www.b2cjewels.com/Round/1/5992/Diamond-Accent-Settings/Petite-Channel-Set-Round-Diamond-Engagement-Ring-14K-White-Gold-(1-5-cttw).aspx

http://www.b2cjewels.com/Round/1/6395/Diamond-Accent-Settings/Cathedral-Diamond-Engagement-Ring-14K-White-Gold-(1-5-cttw..).aspx

http://www.b2cjewels.com/Round/1/6203/Diamond-Accent-Settings/Cathedral-Pave-Set-Round-Diamond-Engagement-Ring-14K-White-Gold-(1-4-cttw..).aspx

http://www.b2cjewels.com/Round/1/6470/Diamond-Accent-Settings/Cathedral-Round-Diamond-Engagement-Ring-14K-White-Gold.aspx

What's your favorite guys for a 1.52 round diamond, 4.5 ring size, small hand?

And yes, I'll definately post pics Enerchi!
 
I don't know if it is just me, but only the last link worked...

90% rain, huh??? Well, we are in Ontario, Canada, so maybe your area is far better than ours! Hmmm... wonder what the 28th year will bring? they say rain on your wedding day is a good thing to bring you luck in love ... ya, they have to spin it somehow, right?? LOL!
 
deezy455|1370917652|3463150 said:
Wow 28 years..Congrats Enrichi!

Yes I do feel comfortable since:
- It got a 0.6 HCA score
- Got an excellent cut GIA score
- The Sales guy at B2C reccomended this one over #4 (I'm assuming I can trust him)
- Twining wisps aren't "that" bad of an inclusion, so should be eye clean

I guess these are good enough reasons for me to buy without seeing an ASET image. Plus on those other sites you mentioned, for this price range I would have to go down .2 karats to about a 1.3 karat.
Click to expand...

If these reasons are good enough for you, go for it ! Without an ASET to compare, your best bet is to trust the sales/gemologist at B2C :)

With regards, to setting, i prefer a simpler or more flowly settings so i would prefer setting 1 or 2 :)
 
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Jewelry Blog
PriceScope-Concierge-Ad
Find prime cuts.
Top