Diamond ACA 1 or ACA 2?

[BrownyJones]

Hi all, thanks for the previous comments. Which diamond would you chose? Both are ACAs, same specs, prices are essentially the same. I can't decide between a few feathers at the girdle, or a few darker inclusions in the table that is eye clean, but maybe visible if seen close up.

 

[JDDN]

As long as the gemologist has said the feathers do not pose durability risks, then that is what I'd choose. Ask if the feather(s) are propagable (hidden by a prong). Dark boogers under the table are a no go for me personally.

 

[Gypsy]

What is the clarity grade? We can't tell you anything without that. An SI2 feather at the girdle is a problem. A VVS is not.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

I agree, need to know clarity grade and diameter measurements.

I remember that first stone...was it SI1?

 

[BrownyJones]

Yes, sorry, both SI1.