I would get a plain band the same profile as the band and a diamond eternity ring for first anniversary (again same width & height) I love a plain wedding band, when I was married I never took mine off.
Congratulations! Classic beautiful ring. Enjoy!
So beautiful, congrats to you! How exciting to have a surprise engagement. I've been engaged 3 times and never surprised. I feel I've missed out!!
I havn't been engagement once
If it makes you feel better, only one was worth while! I wouldn't wish the other two on anybody.