David Klass CAD help

[Josh_loveofjewels]

Hello all!

I am about to have David send me a model for this ring.
What are your opinions on the shape of the scrolls?

 

[tyty333]

Why does the opening look small and awkward in the top cad and look a little more fluid and graceful in the bottom cads?e

Edit ...I would probably bring the point of the opening down even further than the second cad as long as it stays structurally safe.

 

[Josh_loveofjewels]

sorry, I should have explained that they are two different CADs. I had him make the change so things were a little more round, but I feel that I liked it better before.

 

[tyty333]

I dont care for the first one at all.

 

[Mooshi]

That looks SO COOL! Good choice on having a model sent. I also vote bottom CAD.