Cut advisor

[jddiamond]

How come a seemingly nice cut stone in terms of table and depth % (55, 61.9) gives a not so nice score when put into the HCA, the angles are 35.0 and 41.2. How accurate is this and could a score of 2 or 2.2 or even 3.5 really been differentiated with the naked eye.

 

[togal]

You may want to check out this article: http://www.goodoldgold.com/Technologies/AConsumersGuidetotheHCA/http://you/

 

[jddiamond]

WOW! The HCA actually confuses me. I just found a seemingly nice stone with a score of 2 and it said buy if the price is right. Come on. Is this really any different that a score of 1.8 and if the depth and table are very nearly ideal range, who cares what the score is? Am I missing something???