CUSHION CUT EXPERTS, PLEASE HELP

[samanthajane]

I am currently hunting for a square shaped cushion cut diamond, wanting something close to the 7mm x 7mm mark, which is around a 1.75ct. I have found one i am interested in online, it has all the criteria i am after, but i am worried as i do not want a diamond with the "crushed ice" look. It is GIA certified, how do i figure out whether it is a nice facet structure? Please help!!

 

[pandabee]

Post a picture of the diamond so that we can help you determine whether the stone is indeed not a "crushed ice" look that you are trying to avoid. Even better if you have an ASET (the red/green image that shows light return).

 

[samanthajane]

I do not have a photo of the diamond, all i have is the GIA certificate. i know this is risky but i can send back for a full refund if not happy with it, just dont want to go through the hassle of doing that. Attached is the diagram of the diamond on the GIA certificate, im not sure whether this can indicate whether it has a good facet structure?

 

[Christina...]

I would highly encourage you to shop with a vendor that can offer you images of the actual stone you will be purchasing. I understand that this vendor has a good return policy, but the fact is, the majority of cushions cut have a 'crushed ice' appearance. Finding a well cut cushion with large bold facet structures can be challenging, to do it blind would be absolutely frustrating to me, not to mention costly to return time and time again, even if return shipping is free for you, most vendors only allow for a certain number of returns before they too grow frustrated of incurring the expense.

Many vendors offer the type of cushion you are looking for, Good Old Gold, Engagement RIngs Direct, Leon Mege, Victor Canera, and of course you could consider an actual antique which can be found through Old World Diamonds, and Jewels by Erica Grace. All of these vendors can offer you actual photos of the diamond, but more importantly can assess the stone in person and offer information of the stones potential light performance. I realize that these services come with an added cost, but it would be well worth it to me, especially if I factored in the potential savings of having to return many stones (assuming of course that you have to pay for return shipping).

We can help make suggestions for you if you'd like.


ETA I'm not sure what the clarity grade of this particular stone is, but if it is in the SI range, then I would also be concerned about the inclusions on the table. The crystals on the table could be white or black, eye clean or not, the cloud could reduce light performance (or not) if that is a concern for you, then it's another reason that working with a vendor that can actual see, assess and provide actual images is important.

 

[yennyfire]

I agree with Christina about going with a vendor who will send you photos of the stones you are considering. For any fancy cut, this is critical. I wouldn't even consider buying a stone sight unseen. If you aren't set on using this vendor, some of the more experienced cushion "hunters" can help you find a stone that meets your criteria and is beautiful to look at...