by Bowierock » Jun 30, 2019 Hello all, I’m deciding between 2 diamonds, which one do you think is better? Diamond # 1 - https://www.bluenile.com/hk/diamond-details/LD12378623 0.9 J VS1 6.12 x 6.16 x 3.85 62.7 depth 56 table 36 crown 40.6 pavilion HCA 1.7 Gia XXX Diamonds # 2 https://www.bluenile.com/hk/diamond-details/LD12587997 0.9 I SI1 6.19 x 6.15 x 3.82 mm 62 depth 56 table 34.5 crown 40.6 pavilion GIA XXX HCA 0.8 Should be eye clean Diamond 2 looks good to me and better colour but the arrows are not as sharp. also the HCA is 0.8 and I read that there’s a general consensus that under 1 HCA score could be a concern? Should I be worried about and HCA 0.8? I won’t be able to check with IS or AEST so have to rely on the videos and specs. Diamond 1 is J colour but seems to be very clean and white looking, maybe because it is VS1? Which would be a better buy? Looking for your expert opinions, thanks very much!!