Changing out ring .....need help

[Undecided79]

I am changing out my setting for an anniversary and need an opinion. I am posting my two choices . I have very long skinny fingers. It will be my one carat princess cut stone . Also the first pic is w a simulated 2ct diamond ,not real or mine. I really can't pick.

 

[Ally T]

I like the first setting because your finger can take it. Go big, or go home

 

[Undecided79]

I like the first setting because your finger can take it. Go big, or go home

I like the first setting because your finger can take it. Go big, or go home

Like this way of thinking . Thankyou

 

[luv2sparkle]

It is really hard to tell with the photos but I am leaning towards the first one also. It has a little more interest to me. For some reason, I am not drawn to the two row settings.

 

[Undecided79]

 

[Undecided79]

It is really hard to tell with the photos but I am leaning towards the first one also. It has a little more interest to me. For some reason, I am not drawn to the two row settings.

I posted better pics !

 

[AprilBaby]

I voted 2 even tho I like 1 better. I feel like 1 looks better with a round and 2 looks better with a princess.

 

[pregcurious]

Is the whole thing the setting, or are there bands? What about getting a simple solitaire and getting a bands to stack with it?

 

[Undecided79]

Is the whole thing the setting, or are there bands? What about getting a simple solitaire and getting a bands to stack with it?

Hi there. So they both are a ring and a band. The one looks like 3 bands in one w an additional band . The other one is a double band w a band. Both sold as a set.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

What we will generally tell you around here is that a really wide band with a 1 ct stone is going to make your diamond look smaller. However, between these two, I like the style of the second one better, but I honestly do not think it will look proportional with a 1 ct stone.

 

[Undecided79]

What we will generally tell you around here is that a really wide band with a 1 ct stone is going to make your diamond look smaller. However, between these two, I like the style of the second one better, but I honestly do not think it will look proportional with a 1 ct stone.

You think the diamond will weird ? Here is a pic of it w the one carat simulated

 

[diamondseeker2006]

No, I was referring more to the second one that you said had a 2 ct CZ. That last picture showing the 1ct cz looks fine. If it were me, though, I'd put the diamond in a narrower ring with maybe a 2-2.5mm shank and make the wedding band a little wider. But I think the one you just posted will work with your stone if it's the same size as the CZ.

 

[Undecided79]

Really wish I wasn't so I decisive !!! I can't make a choice for nothing . I keep going back and forth. Am I the only one ? Lol

 

[diamondseeker2006]

You are far from being the only one!!! In fact, I'd say the majority here are somewhat indecisive (including ME!!), and people here change settings ALL THE TIME!!!!

My best advice is to take your time! There are SO many settings to choose from!

 

[Undecided79]

You are far from being the only one!!! In fact, I'd say the majority here are somewhat indecisive (including ME!!), and people here change settings ALL THE TIME!!!!

My best advice is to take your time! There are SO many settings to choose from!

So I went today to jewelry exchange. I'm sure you see the commercials and found this I loved a lot. What are your thoughts ?