Cant decide Between 2 Stones

[Honrad]

Hi,

Been browsing through numberous forum and website to learn more abt diamond before deciding to buy one for my proposal. I had been offered 2 stones and i had plough through the stats and still end up pretty confuse which one to buy. So wondering annyone can comment on the stones listed below for my reference to make the decision. Thks in advance.

Stone 1
Round Brilliant
5.85-5.87 x3.52mm
0.74, H VS2
Cut, Polish,Sys: All excellent
Clarity Characteristics: Cloud Finish
Depth: 60.1%
Table:60%
Crown Angle:33.0 Deg
Crown Height: 13%
Pavillion Angle: 41 Deg
Pavillion Depth:43.5%
Star length :55%
Lower half :80%
Girdle: Med to Stk
Faceted (3.8%)
Culeet: N
FL:N
Price: USD2733

Stone 2

Round Brilliant
5.77-5.81 x3.56mm
0.73, H SI1
Cut, Polish,Sys: All excellent
Clarity Characteristics: Twinning Wisp, Cloud Finish
Depth: 61.5%
Table:57%
Crown Angle:35.0 Deg
Crown Height: 15%
Pavillion Angle: 40.8 Deg
Pavillion Depth:43%
Star length :55%
Lower half :80%
Girdle: Med to Stk
Faceted (3.4%)
Culeet: N
FL:N
Price:USD2253

Feel free to comment and again thks.

 

[stone-cold11]

If #2 is eye-clean, I would prefer that.

 

[Lorelei]

Welcome!

Have you seen these diamonds in person? They are both different types of stone with the first being a 60 60 type which some like, the second has the more usual sort of proportions. Going by the info we have I would pick the second one, but if they are with an online vendor and you haven't seen the diamonds, ask for an Idealscope image for both.

https://www.pricescope.com/idealscope_indx.asp

Check that the second diamond is eyeclean to your standards.