Anyone have any advise on which stone?

[rmoore116]

I have been looking for a pricess cut 2 plus carat stone and I think I have come to the two finalists. The basic difference is the size and the color. I would apperciate any advise anyone may have.

GIA, 2.35, F, VS2, $18653, Depth: 71.7, Table: 70.00, Polish: VG, Symmetry: VG, No Fluorescence, 7.33 X 7.27 X 5.21


GIA, 2.01, E, VS2, $17413, Depth 72.20, Table: 70,
Polish: Excellent, Symmetry: VG, No Fluorescence, 6.81 X 6.81 X 4.92

Thanks

 

[moremoremore]

OK- this is SOOOOO just a guess, but what is with #2....why is it so small? It's not that deep...Wonder what the crown hight is....interesting. I like #1...it's got a good spread so I am thinking that it could be a great stone. Pass on #2 only b/c it's really small for its carat weight...What about the girdle? No X thin?

 

[moremoremore]

p.s.- You won't be able to see the diff b/w the E and F...and this is coming from ME who is ultra sensitive....Good job on the stones btw!

 

[rmoore116]

I have the crown height and girdle info for the 2.01 diamond. The Crown Height is 12.9 and the girdle is 3.8 (thick)

Thanks for the advice!