Adding Diamond to Drop Diamond Pendant

[WillyDiamond]

I want to add a diamond to my wife's drop diamond pendant. It was done a few years ago by WF and she loves it but I always wanted to add a 6th stone (currently it has 5 stones). Decided to add a .40/.41 carat stone at the bottom. Picture attached (sorry, terrible, terrible picture). Current size of the stones are .25, .15, .12, .10 and .08, all F/G, VS, ACA melee collection.

I am looking at 3 stones by WF: (All AGS graded)

Diamond#1:

.41 ct, F/VS2
Cut = Excellent
Depth = 61.4, Table = 56.8, Crown = 34.7, Pavillion = 40.6
Culet = pointed, Flour = neg
Meas: 4.76 - 4.79 -2.93
Girdle = thin to medium faceted
Light perform, Polish, Symmetry = Ideal, Exc, Ideal

Diamond#2:

.404 ct, G/VS
Cut = Ideal
Depth - 61.7, Table = 54.4, Pavillion = 40.8, Crown = 34.2
Culet = pointed, Flour = neg
Meas 4.74 - 4.76 - 2.93
Thin to Slightly Thick
Light Perform, Polish, Symmetry = Ideal, ideal, Ideal

Diamond#3:

.405 ct, G/VS
Cut = Ideal
Depth = 61.9, Table = 55.2, pavillion 40.8, crown 34.6
Culet = pointed, Flour = neg
Meas: 4.74 - 4.78 - 2.94
Light Perform, Polish, Symmetry = Ideal, Ideal, Ideal

I have purposely left off price, want to see how you rate the stone. Thanks.

 

[chrono]

Missing the crown info for diamonds #2 and #3.

 

[WillyDiamond]

Missing the crown info for diamonds #2 and #3.

Thanks Chrono, just edited to add the crown angles.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Is your wife asking for an extra diamond to be added? That's fine if that is what she wants. But I personally would keep it as it is. I think 5 looks right and 6 would be too many.

All of those stones are certainly fine.

 

[WillyDiamond]

Is your wife asking for an extra diamond to be added? That's fine if that is what she wants. But I personally would keep it as it is. I think 5 looks right and 6 would be too many.

All of those stones are certainly fine.

Excellent point, DS2006, thanks.