Your thoughts on these diamonds for earrings?

[bellajanie84]

I'm looking to purchase stud and was sent these 2 diamonds matched by IDJ.
They said both our eye clean but 1 of the diamonds has alot of blemishes to my eye, will you ladies with more expertise give me feedback?
Both are SI1

 

[OoohShiny]

What size are the stones?

At what distance would you prefer 'eye-clean'? (and how does that match with IDJ's eye-clean distance?)

Don't forget that they are vastly enlarged on-screen, so in real life any inclusions will be pin-prick tiny. They will also be well-hidden by white light and coloured fire sparkles in most situations!

 

[bellajanie84]

1.2 tcw

 

[tyty333]

FYI
You might get more help if you just had
1-aset image
1-ideal scope image
1-real image
1- hearts image
1- arrow image
Per stone.

I scrolled through and took a pass because there are multiple images of the same type of the same stone...I think. 14 images for 2 stones
means people have to stop and figure out whats going on. Plus, you dont have a divider between stone 1 and stone 2 images. Its easier
to give opinions when we dont have to stop and figure out the puzzle of what image goes with what stone and have we already viewed this
image previously (copy of a previous image)?

Hopefully with time some more PSers will be willing to figure out what belongs to what and offer some opinions.

 

[lovedogs]

I think these look nice for earrings. I trust IDJ, and if they say these are eye clean a X viewing distance then I trust them. No one is inspecting earrings close up anyway, so mostly you want ones that sparkle (e.g. excellent cut).