I'm sorry, headlight, but this is mistaken; as I said in response to a similar post of yours in AugustI don’t know what carriers are available in Canada. But as a general education, there are 2 types of policies: Replacement and reimbursement. One will work with a jeweler (either your preference or yours, need to ascertain the policy) to replace like for like. Or they give you a straight payout based on insured value.* * * Jewelers Mutual is a very quality company with basically no inclusions and a straight payout yet they are a bit higher in cost. * * *
- Jewelers Mutual's standard policy is not one whereby you can expect they will write you a no-strings-attached check. JM's "selling point," repeated on a number of their web pages, is that you use a jeweler of your choice (i.e., unlike most other insurance companies that offer personal jewelry policies, JM doesn't dictate the source of the replacement or repair) & the jeweler is who receives payment from JM. See, e.g., the first FAQ -- Can I receive cash? -- on their Claims info page:
JM will write a free-and-clear check only if the coverage amount is lower than what it would cost to repair/replace the item -- or if they agreed to issue an "agreed-upon value" [ETA or "declared value"] policy with the more expensive premiums.