2 ct diamond advise please!!!

[mai_gosh]

Hi! I am upgrading to a 2 ct. It's a GIA diamond. My only concerns is the "I" color and SI1 clarity. Currently I have a 1 ct F color I1 diamond. The HCA for the 2 ct is 1.4 and received 3 excellent out of 4 of the criteria. Here is the GIA report. The diamond is 22k and with my trade in it will be 15k. What are your thoughts?!? I need help deciding.

 

[lollipoplady]

This might sound silly, but if you have a Costco nearby, all their stones are I color or better. You could pop in there and see what you think without any pressure or hassle if you want to see IRL before buying.