Girdle thin-very thick?

[chadt0123]

Girdle thickness for a princess cut diamond, what is the best?

GIA Certificate on one that I am currently looking at:
Shape and Cutting Style......Square Modified Brilliant
Measurements...............6.17 x 6.15 x 3.95 mm
Weight.................................1.21 carat
Proportions
Depth.......................................64.2%
Table.......................................69.0%
Girdle...............Extremely Thin to Very Thick
Culet........................................NONE
Finish
Polish..................................VERY GOOD
Symmetry.....................................GOOD
Clarity Grade......................................VS2
Color Grade..........................................H
Flourescence.................................NONE

I''ve read on this site the 65/65 Table/Depth Q?A did anyone come to a conclusion. The above diamond is quoted around $5400. Good BUY?

 

[antonia]

I'm no expert but the diamond I was looking at had a big range in girdle and the folk on here advised me that it could result in light leakage and that I should check out the IdealScope... perhaps you can do the same....

Good luck.

 

[dimonbob]

An extremely thin girdle on a Princess cut is not what you want. Of course it be only extremely thin in one extremely small spot in which case it would be ok.