Which one is a better deal?
.467 round cut, color F, clarity SI1. Table %=56, Depth%60.7, Pavilion%43.1, Crown Angle=33.9 Girdle=0.7%-1.2%. Measurements is 5.03-5.06x3.06. This is selling for $1196.00

The second one:
.453 round cut, color G, clarity VS2. Table%=55, Depth %=61, Pavilion%=43, Crown=34.8, Girdle=1.0%-1.2%. Measurements is 4.97-5.00x3.04. This is selling for $1205.10.

They both seem very good to me but I think the first was is a better deal? What is everyone esle's opinion?

I got these quotes from www.whiteflash.com. Are they a good online diamond distributor?
I checked on your online vendor list but found nothing much about Whiteflash.

Whiteflash is a very reputable distributor of A Cut Above brand hearts and arrows diamonds. They sell them at very good prices.

If you go to this link on pricescope you can see the strict standards they uphold for their hearts and arrows diamonds.
http://www.pricescope.com/hearts_indx.asp

You can try these diamonds in the cut adviser on pricescope to see how they may perform. I guess you'll have to call them for the pavilion angle as they only list the percentage.
http://www.pricescope.com/cutadviser.asp

You may also want to go through the video and tutorial first. You may feel more confident about your purchase if you do so.

I hope this is helpful.

lawmax

Whiteflash is a very good online vendor, and the Cut Above product is one of the best branded H&A diamonds I've seen.

Good luck, and let us know what you purchase.