gold vs. silver

I think both stand up to daily wear pretty well - they just have a different look. i think silver is harder for jeweler to work with than with gold. Silver rings on my leave a black tarnish on my skin... Which gold doesnt.

I prefer white gold. Silver tarnishes too quickly for me to wear everyday, whereas I''m really lucky as far as white gold goes - I haven''t had to replate a single piece yet.

well I like white gold as well, however on "fun rings" with gems, that is on the less expensive side, I will buy silver.

I prefer yellow gold for nearly all of my every day jewelry pieces.  You don''t need to replate it like white gold, no allergy problems which white gold can cause, and no tarnishing like silver.  Besides, it looks like gold.

I have worn both silver and gold extensively in everyday rings and found that the gold didn''t bend or become misshapen like the silver did...

gold (whether it be white, yellow or rose) would be less prone to "bruising" and definitely no tarnishing.  if you opt for a lower gold content, the metal will also be harder (ie. 9ct is harder than 22ct) but less valuable. 

silver, though, for everyday wear is good, too.  i suppose, in the end, it''s all about what you want to wear and if you have a preference for either.

sorry....i don''t think i am of much help to you.....

Gold any color, don''t like cleaning silver.

A lot of my semi-precious are set in silver and have lasted for years, but the sapphire ring I wear everyday is white gold and I love it (except for the replating).

Thanks everyone for the advice. I appreciate all the different opinions too.

Supposedly the argentum silver doesn''t tarnish. I have a few and they have yet to tarnish. Yay for a less expensive option !

Date: 8/22/2009 8:32:02 AM
Author: sonomacounty
Supposedly the argentum silver doesn''t tarnish. I have a few and they have yet to tarnish. Yay for a less expensive option !

A few corrections:

Properly worked (heat treated) and cared for argentium is tarnish resistant. This doesn''t mean it never tarnishes (it takes longer to in ordinary situations and can get a yellowish coating that is hard to remove in others - the beachm for example).

I am not a huge fan of argentium and prefer sterling. Then again, silver doesn''t tarnish on me so maybe I am lucky.