Tungsten vs. tianium vs. white gold
Click to view full-size image.
Related topics
- 14K white gold & tungsten
- Tungsten next to white gold?
- White gold wedding band... with tungsten inlay?
- Allergic to white gold (nickel alloy)! Recs for etailers with palladium alloy white gold?
- palladium-white gold or nickel-white gold?
- gold plated tungsten carbide scratch resistant?
- Are there custome tungsten settings available? Also, is Tungsten the most scratch resistant metal?
- can or would you wear a yellow gold accented watch with a white gold wedding ring?
- Yellow gold wedding bands with white gold/platinum engagement rings?
- Is 18k white gold as likely to yellow as 14k white gold
|
|
|
|
by MustangGal » November 12th, 2007, 3:13 pm
I have rings of all three metals, and here''s my thoughts:
White gold, even on a guy that works at a computer, will need replating every once in a while. It''s a nice classic though, and can be sized. My DH has a titanium band he''s been wearing for 4 years straight, and it''s getting pretty scuffed looking, but he loves the light weight feel and the color. He now has a titanium bracelet, necklace, and we''re looking for a watch to match. I have a tungsten band I wear camping/surfing/traveling. It''s HEAVY, like more than platinum, and can withstand anything and still look great. It''s a very dark color, not quite metal looking, but really neat. I''ve had it a year now, and you can''t tell I''ve even worn it. Tungsten can''t be sized though, but you can just buy a new ring for alomst the cost of sizing a gold ring. |
|
|
|
|
I, too, would be interested in hearing more about people''s opinions with Tungsten. And to add to the mix, how it might compare to Platinum? That''s what I''ve narrowed down to.
Where are reputable places to buy Tungsten rings? Hope that adds to the discussion, as I don''t intend to hijack the thread. |
|
|
|
|
In most B&M stores, you can purchase an "extended" warranty for just about anything. This is a good option and something I recommend when it comes to the titanium and Tungsten carbide rings. IMO I''d rather spend the money on the extra warranty for the ring then have to order a new one (and pay for out of my pocket) to fit every so often. Most places have a warranty that will cover the replacement for the ring if you need a different size. Where I work now offers a 3 year, but I know that there are stores that offer a lifetime plan. Anytime your weight flucuates or the temperature changes, you risk your ring not fitting and it will be uncomfortable or you could lose it. These warranties or service plans are definately worth their weight when it comes to these bands.
Good luck with your choice! |
|
|
|
|
So, I understand that Tungsten and Platinum have similar heft. And that Tungsten has a "darker" look.
But, when Tungsten Carbide is polished, how does the colour compare to Platinum or White Gold? Pics on the net don''t make it easy to distinguish. I tend to favour the look of Platinum over White Gold. And I understand the difference between Tungsten and Tungsten Carbide. But, I''ve seen "Tungsten Carbide 857"? Anyone know what this is? Are there differences in quality between Tungsten Carbide mixes/rings? |
|
|
|
|
I have no idea what the difference is between the tungsten types. My ring is darker than platinum, more of a gun metal color. Its pretty neat, but different than white gold or platinum. You can see them in person at most chain jewelry stores, and I think even Wal Mart is carrying titanium and tungsten now. If i have time tonight I''ll try to get a picture together of tungsten, titanium, platinum and white gold, I have ring of all those metals.
|
|
|
|
|
we did as well MG!! my fiance and I originally had matching Titanium bands, and after a period of roughly a year, he was quite unhppy with it and decided to try tungsten.(I upgraded to Platinum) It has been 2 years in January and it still looks brand spanking new. We own a small computer store and he, of course, is working with his hands/dirt/grime all day and it holds up beautifully. If is starts to look a bit dirty, he simply shines it up with his tshirt, LOL. I would highly recommend Tungsten. |
|
|
|
|
My sister was going to buy her husband a titanium ring, but then called local hospitals to find out of they''d be able to cut it off if his hand was ever injured and none of the hospitals had the tools it would take to cut through the titanium band, so she got him a surgical steel ring instead.
While buying my wedding band I asked the jeweller if he thought titanium bands were dangerous and he said the same thing--that only certain hospitals in our area could cut through the band if there was ever an emergency. I was wondering if those with titanium bands had to call their local hospitals first? |
