Royal Asscher vs Generic Asscher Better pics

the RA is slightly squarer to the camera than the other.
I like em both.
Id take the bigger , less costly generic.

the one on the left?

royal asscher



and generic

Thanks belle.  That made it easy, generic!!!

easy is good

you''re welcome

Thank you for the eyecandy!!
Not often I get pictures of 2 kicken asschers in one evening to drool over.
Honestly I dont think you can go wrong with either, pick the one that makes your heart sing :}

I really appreciate your input.  They are both so nice it''s been difficult deciding.  For the past several days I have alternated from the Royal to the generic and back again.  My husband also seems to prefer the generic asscher (though I don''t think it''s because it''s less expensive?).  They really are both very beautiful.

Linda

As Storm says, pick the one that sings to you.  Tough choice!!

RA for RHR? :}

Date: 1/3/2006 7:33:25 PM
Author: belle
royal asscher



and generic

 Where did these pictures go?  Can you guys see them?

 I''s have a hard time deciding between those too ...   judging from the first picture with the two on hand.


 

not showing up here either.

Here is the royal again

Attachments

LindaAZRoyal.jpg (42.94 KiB) Viewed 366 times

What are the specs on these stones?  Is the one on the left the Royal?  To me that one looks a tad clearer.

Generic asscher 1.83, VS1, I 

Attachments

LindaAZgeneric_web.gif (56.91 KiB) Viewed 366 times

Royal Asscher 1.59, VS2, I

In the picture of the two side by side the generic is on the left. 

Attachments

LindaAZRoyal_web.gif (51.6 KiB) Viewed 366 times

The specifications for both diamonds are on the Good Old Gold website:

http://www.goodoldgold.com/1_59ct_i_vs2_royal_asscher.htm
http://www.goodoldgold.com/asscher_1_83ct_i_vs1.htm

still havent decided?
tough choice between 2 kicken asschers.

I am leaning towards the 1.83 again!  I sent them back to Good Old Gold today.  I have to make my final decision by Monday!  The next decision will be the setting.  I probably will go with something similar to the 1922 Cartier reproduction rings I''ve seen on this forum and other diamond websites.

Thanks again to all who provided their input.  It always helps to have other people''s opinions. 

Hope it is not too late to add my .02. I actually like the generic asscher more as well. Of course, I just got a generic asscher e-ring that I LOVE...so I may be biased...but I like the generics more, as a general rule. Less fussy.

Yeah I''m leaning towards the generic too. Tough call. Let us know what you decide!

Yes please let us know your decision.  I still like the generic better, but can''t go wrong with either.  The Cartier repro setting sounds perfect!!!