| Re: Platinum vs Tungsten Carbide for wedding bands |
|
|
|
My husband went the route of a tungsten ring for daily wear since it does not scratch. We bought his on ebay from heavy crown for $35. No need to spend $200 on one. He loves the weight of it and prefers the look of the darker metal.
|
| Re: Platinum vs Tungsten Carbide for wedding bands |
|
|
|
Such a strange dynamic that would make, to spend 200x as much on an engagement ring than on my own wedding band. Really makes you wonder about jewelry and "worth" and all the emotional connotations that go along with it.
|
| Re: Platinum vs Tungsten Carbide for wedding bands |
|
|
|
I have a tungsten band I wear for rough days, like camping, yard work, water park, etc. and I love it. While we did get my DH a gold and diamond band, he wears it about once a year and instead wears a titanium band that never comes off his finger. I get the point above that a woman's e-ring costs way more than a $35 tungsten band, but most men aren't into jewelry to begin with, and can also be much rougher with their hands. My DH works outdoors, and his hobby is fixing up cars. A platinum or gold band would have been a sorry sight after 10 years of wear in situations like that. I'm trying to convince him he needs a new Scott Kay Cobalt band (about $300) for our 10th anniversary next month, and he tells me not to bother
|
| Re: Platinum vs Tungsten Carbide for wedding bands |
|
|
|
We bought my fiance an inexpensive ($50) tungsten ring. He is really happy with it and figures he can just buy a new one in the future if his ring size changes.
|
| Re: Platinum vs Tungsten Carbide for wedding bands |
|
|
|
I wear a tungsten as well. Firstly, after all the spending spree from everything (wedding, etc), I felt like I didn't need another big expense and secondly, I wanted something that'll survive anything --much like what mustangal said. Car work, outdoor stuff, grit, grime.
|
| Re: Platinum vs Tungsten Carbide for wedding bands |
|
|
|
My son-in-law got his wedding band from Tungsten World. They do exchange for free if your size ever changes. It looks great and is amazingly scratch resistant!
|
| Re: Platinum vs Tungsten Carbide for wedding bands |
|
|
|
Wow, I have to say I'm surprised that nobody's jumped in saying "Forget that stuff, go platinum all the way!" Makes me wonder if platinum was as inexpensive as tungsten carbide whether anybody would choose it. Still, the ability to have it resized if needed holds a lot of sway. When I lost my first wedding band from a previous marriage and got a replacement, it did suck knowing it wasn't the original.
|
| Re: Platinum vs Tungsten Carbide for wedding bands |
|
|
|
Forget that stuff, either go all the way or don't wear a ring!!!!
This is a matter of romance, tradition and an advanced celebration of longevity. These days, the modern metals have surely given people wonderful alternatives. We are so modern in so many respects, how can you fight what looks like progress. Something highly attractive, very durable, and less costly. Somebody is going to figure out how to make a halo ring, or a solitaire style in one of these new metals and before you know it, there will be many alternatives to gold, platinum and silver in lady's engagement ring jewelry, too. Jewelers are driven to sell consumers what consumers have decided they wish to buy. Fashion leaders influence consumers attitudes. Whatever the consumer wants will dictate the process in the long run and there are no real reasons behind any particular choice of metal other than the practical reasons of these metals being up to the task of being properly formed, holding stones securely and reasonably durable in finish. We have yet to solve the problem of re-sizing many of the exotic metals when they are made into rings. David S. Atlas, GG(GIA) Sr Mbr(NAJA) ASG(AGA) My basket of services available to Pricescopers |
| Re: Platinum vs Tungsten Carbide for wedding bands |
|
|
|
Have you seen the Cobalt ones? http://www.scottkay.com/skcobalt/ they claim they can size them, yet are still more durable than regular metals. This is what I want to get DH this time around. They are a little more pricey then tungsten, but still way less than gold. |
| Re: Platinum vs Tungsten Carbide for wedding bands |
|
|
|
My husband's original wedding band is a Palladium Scott Kay. The scratches were driving him batty (he's not a 'patina' guy) so I got him a Tungsten. He loves it and gets so many compliments on it.
They do have "emergency" Tungsten kits. If you are in a bad situation and need the ring OFF there are kits that will break the ring. Yes the ring gets destroyed, but you keep your finger. We paid 20 bucks for his. At that price I can replace them every year. The Palladium ring (which sits in a box) was 1100 three years ago. I totally think the Tungsten is the way to go. |
| Re: Platinum vs Tungsten Carbide for wedding bands |
|
|
|
I have both...a platinum eternity band and a plain band to wear with my e-ring and a tungsten ring to wear on it's own. I wouldn't mix platinum and tungsten...I won't wear my tungsten against my platinum e-ring. However, for my job as a nurse, the tungsten has held up incredibly well, hasn't scratched and is very durable for the $20 investment. If I lose it, it's easily replaceable. I think it's a matter of lifestyle and preference rather than cost. For me, both work and have different uses.
|
| Re: Platinum vs Tungsten Carbide for wedding bands |
|
|
|
Does anybody know of any color comparison charts that show the difference in color/sheen between platinum, tungsten carbode, or even white tungsten carbide? I tried looking but couldn't find much.
|
| Re: Platinum vs Tungsten Carbide for wedding bands |
|
|
|
Tungsten carbide sounded perfect for my fiance since it doesn't scratch (the scratching on my own platinum ring drives me crazy), but I ordered one from etsy ($20!) and didn't know that it was such a dark metal. Tungsten is gunmetal colored, I see that some companies sell "white tungsten" as well, which I've never seen.
Also, even the jeweler (PS Vendor) said not to bother with anything too expensive for a guy - they lose these pretty often. And they don't seem to care what it's made of anyway. I ended up ordering him a classic 14k white gold band instead. |