Post by boileratc » November 2nd, 2009, 9:52 am
4246113 class="postbitlinks">Ok, so I bought an engagement ring but decided against buying the center diamond from the store because they were offering an awful price. I need some help buying a center stone.

Here''s what I''m looking for:
1) Certified by AGS, GIA, or EGL (preference in that order)
2) Carat >1.0
3) Color anywhere from D-G
4) Cut: ideal or excellent
5) Clarity: need a little help here, IF-SI1? Is SI1 too low, should I stick with VS2 and higher?

Here''s my options so far:
Option 1) EGL certified, 1.04 carat, G, exclusive ideal cut, VS2. I have the measurements and they are all excellent/ideal (depth, table, polish, symmetry, etc). Comes with appraisal, certificate, and 30 day money back guarantee, free shipping, no tax. Price: $3,594.

Option 2) EGL certified, 1.20 carat, G, premium cut (1 step below option 1), VS2. Table width is 1% too wide for ideal plus, still considered ideal though. This diamond has been clarity enhanced. Comes with appraisal, certificate, 7 day money back guarantee, no tax, free shipping. Price: $2,650.

Option 3) EGL certified, 1.27 carat, E, exclusive ideal cut, SI1. Comes with certificate, 7 day money back guarantee, no tax, free shipping. Price: $3,600 or best offer.

I know I said GIA and AGS were preferred but they seem to be a bit out of my price range with a carat >1.0.  Any stone I buy will be taken to a jeweler and re-appraised immediately. 

Does it matter that I don''t plan to ever sell the diamond and that my fiance is not "jewelry smart" (meaning she doesn''t know what any of the 4 c''s mean other than carat).

Any help with choosing the best diamond is greatly appreciated. Thanks.