Emerald Cut Opinions needed

[annieb08]

Could you please give me your opinion on these two emerald cuts. The 2.5 is on the right in the picture.

#1
Carat Weight: 2.5 ct
Color: H
Clarity: VS1
Polish: Excellent
Symmetry: Good
Flr: None
Measurements: 8.42X 6.65 X 4.62mm
Table%: 62%
Depth%: 69.5%
Girdle: Thick-V Thick

#2
Carat Weight: 2.43 ct
Color: G
Clarity: VS1
Polish: VG
Symmetry: VG
Flr: None
Measurements: 8.62X 6.59 X 4.36mm
Table%: 60%
Depth%: 66.2%
Girdle: Medium

 

[chrono]

Are you saying the 2.5 is on the right and the 2.43 is on the left?

The picture is kind of small. Can you get a bigger picture? How about a side view to show the crown height? I''m a bit leary of the Good symmetry on the 2.5ct EC but that picture looks promising. It''s just hard to tell because I can barely make out the details of the steps.

 

[annieb08]

Thanks for the reply Chrono.

Yes, the 2.43 is on the left and the 2.5 is on the right.

I have requested crown height numbers. I will see if I can get some bigger pictures.

 

[strmrdr]

bigger/better pictures.
Also ask why the symmetry is only good on the first and if its eye visible.