feedback on these four rings?

[jeffd]

Hi,

thinking about these rings for my wife. Would welcome any and and all feedback on quality, price, like/don't like of these rings.
tia,
jd

https://www.artdecodiamonds.com/products.php?id=574&l=0&u=2147483647&sortway=asc
https://www.artdecodiamonds.com/products.php?id=234&l=0&u=2147483647&sortway=asc
https://www.artdecodiamonds.com/products.php?id=1135&l=0&u=2147483647&sortway=asc
https://www.artdecodiamonds.com/products.php?id=2255&l=0&u=2147483647&sortway=asc

 

[Circe]

The first two are reproductions, and the workmanship looks wonky: the third looks like a genuine antique, with a nicely colored emerald, overall quite beautiful; and the fourth, though a nice design with good workmanship, is a little darker than what I like in a ruby. I vote for #3, hands down!

 

[Rebecca0388]

Another vote for the emerald, so pretty.

Just a thought, that ring is platinum and yellow gold, and the others are white gold. Does your wife have a preference? I personally wear white and yellow so it wouldn't bother me

 

[arkieb1]

Another vote for the emerald. For that sort of money you would also find something nice on Rubylane or on Ebay.

 

[Circe]

Another vote for the emerald. For that sort of money you would also find something nice on Rubylane or on Ebay.

Oh, my, yes - RubyLane is having a big sale on Saturday. You could, for example, get a 5-carat+ diamond bracelet for only $300 more ....

http://www.rubylane.com/item/514555-rl-1009/5-6-Carat-Diamond-Bracelet

 

[Snuffles_Rose]

I love the emerald! Have you checked eriebasin, langantiques, or trumpetandhorn.com? They have some pretty vintage pieces too.