comparing 2 emerald cuts

[surfcandy]

hello all. using the wealth of knowledge here on pricescope, i have narrowed my search down to the following 2 stones. any input would be most appreciated.

1.
GIA
2.64ct emerald cut
9.20x6.82x4.61
67.6 depth%
66 table%
10 crown % (sarin)
Med/thick girdle
No culet
H/VS1
EX/VG/N
$18573

2.
GIA
2.47ct emerald cut
9.92x6.44x4.12
64.0 depth%
68.0 table %
9.9 crown % (sarin)
Sl thick/thick girdle
No culet
F/VS1
G/G/N
$20260

thanks in advance!
howard.

 

[windowshopper]

howard--i think the first stone is better cut and will be sparklier with more character. the second --i believe-- will appear flat. in addition you will save some money
ws