|
|
|
|
I saw the Diane Sawyer/Mel Gibson interview. I applaude how he handled her on the issue of his father. He answered her questions about what he believes happened in the Holocaust. Basically what history has recorded. When she pressed him about his father, Mel told her he loves his father and to leave it alone. Don't go there. And he wouldn't answer any further questions about his father.
The New York reporter that started stirring this pot, has written 3 articles on "Passion", and has not even seen the movie. How's that for objective journalism??!!
|
|
|
|
|
One doesn't have to see the movie to have an opinion on aspects of it which have been very, very widely publicized. Nor does one have to see the movie to have an opinion on the senior Mr. Gibson's anti-semitism. Call me jaded, but I wonder if Jesus, as portrayed by Mel Gibson, will look Semitic and dress like a Jew or if he will look like the Renaissance Jesuses who look more Norwegian than Semitic. I wonder if Mr. Gibson even *knew* how Jews of the period dressed. I *have* read opinion written by scholars of the period on the languages used in the film (where is the Greek?) and about crucifixion (the dearth of skeltal evidence about how it was inflicted). I would never watch the movie not for *POLITICAL* reasons, but because I am not sufficiently masochistic to subject myself to it! I have opinions on it, though!!! |
|
|
|
|
The reporter I was referring to, and I do wish I could remember his name, wrote the articles MONTHS ago. Like AUGUST. He wrote 3 articles about "Passion" right around the time a test viewing with a Jewish audience was held. The reporter, himself, was not invited to the showing. He also had not seen any clips when he wrote his articles. He was not quoting the views of people who had seen the film. He was voicing an opinion on something he had not seen. That journalist's articles were the impetus for the storm that has embroiled the film.
I don't have thoughts one way or the other about the film. Historically correct? Lots of "subject" movies aren't. Mel Gibson has repeatedly said this film is HIS vision. What HE believes. What the Scriptures have said to HIM. I'll wait to see the movie and form my own opinion. ![]() |
|
|
|
|
I don't know about anyone else, but I am wondering if anyone has seen the movie in previews or anything. I actually wanted to see the portray (Mel or not) because my interest in the era was totally sparked by the book The Da Vinci Code. So many questions left unanswered. Actually a few of Dan Brown's books have been that way, and the religious ones have left me curious to see other points of view (even if they are incorrect) because there is always something to learn. All the hype is just to boost sales, especially with a religiously slanted movie such as the PASSION OF CHRIST...I mean really...
|
|
|
|
|
We appear to be similar in that works of fiction can pique our curiosity :-). I have always tended to go off on tangents, immersing myself in research after a movie or book suddenly provided me with interesting, "new" material! I remember the movie "The Lion in Winter" starting avid research into the real life of Eleanor of Aquitaine and Henry II. Similarly the PBS television series "The Six Wives of Henry VIII" gave me a lot of material about which to read. If one adds to that that PBS had a series, "Elizabeth R" and that I loved the movie, "Mary, Queen of Scots"...well, we have taken care of all the religious struggles in England since Henry VIII divorced Catherine of Aragon and broke with the Roman Catholic Church! Deb |
|
|
|
|
Ooooh! AGBF you have me totally interested! I have never been a history buff, but lately I have been reading these depictions with new eyes! What may have started me was a book I read a while ago, The Twentieth Wife, about Empress Noor Jahan of the 17th Century Mugal Empire in India. Talk about a strong lady!!! That book followed up with The Feast of Roses, the second book, and it was good, but not like the first. Then I saw The Red Tent, and was intrigued by the story of Dinah, another stronger woman story, and I have been interested in finding more books about history and especially the history of women. Da Vinci Code had some good elements, and I considered looking into the stories of Cleopatra and Helen of Troy, but have yet to find good historical books about either yet... Any other good recommendations? I am putting these on my list!
![]() |
|
|
|
|
|